Evolution

The between sex genetic correlation for traits has long been hypothesized as a constraint to the evolution of sexual dimorphism. Both empirical and theoretical work has suggested that this constraint is influenced by genotype-sex-environment interactions. We examine genotype-sex-environment interactions in both sexually exaggerated and non-exaggerated legs of Drosophila prolongata, to examine the role of organismal condition on evolvability of an extreme trait. We employed a nested full-sib half-sib crossing design, providing food either ad libitum, or restricting food during larval growth, to each brood. When provided food ad libitum, inter-sex genetic correlations between traits is high and positive, whereas under food restriction this correlation substantially weakens, with a modest negative sign. Similarly, comparisons of the G matrix across sexes becomes less associated under food restriction. We discuss these results in the context of the growing appreciation of the factors that facilitate sex-specific evolutionary change.

High investment in current reproduction can limit future reproductive opportunities, but how selection shapes these hormone-mediated traits remains poorly understood. Androgens can mediate male reproductive investment, and in three-spined stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus), exert antagonistic effects on breeding effort versus spermatogenesis. To understand how shifts in reproductive strategy shape this tradeoff, we compared testes transcriptomes and androgen production between two recently diverged stickleback ecotypes that differ in reproductive strategy: the ancestral "common" ecotype, which provides paternal care, and the non-parental "white" ecotype, which has lost paternal care and prioritizes mating effort. During typical breeding, testes gene expression differed little between ecotypes. However, under prolonged summer-like conditions, testes gene expression diverged substantially. Common-biased genes were enriched for meiotic functions and spermatogenic cell type markers, suggesting commons had initiated spermatogenesis while whites had not. Instead, whites expressed higher levels of steroidogenic candidate genes and released significantly more 11-ketotestosterone than commons, indicating sustained investment in current reproduction. F1 hybrids released 11-ketosterone at intermediate rates, suggesting a genetic basis for this divergence. Sustained androgen production in whites may possibly delay the transition into spermatogenesis, limiting investment in future reproduction. These results illustrate how selection on hormonally-integrated traits can drive rapid divergence in life history strategy.

Avoiding fertilization with genetically incompatible partners, whether too similar or too divergent, is a central challenge for sexually reproducing organisms. Selection can favor mechanisms acting before and after mating, with postmating processes potentially compensating for constraints on premating choice. In the postmating context, female reproductive fluid (FRF) can modulate sperm performance and bias fertilization outcomes, but its contribution to reproductive isolation remains unclear. We tested whether FRF mediates discrimination against heterospecific and related sperm in two naturally hybridizing sister species of swordtails, Xiphophorus birchmanni and X. malinche, that diverge in premating behavior towards heterospecifics. Effects of FRF differed sharply between species. In X. malinche, FRF enhanced the velocity of conspecific sperm relative to heterospecifics, consistent with postmating discrimination against hybridization. In contrast, FRF in X. birchmanni did not favor conspecific sperm. Evidence for inbreeding avoidance was weaker, and we found no indication of a trade-off between discrimination against genetically similar and dissimilar sperm. These results show that female reproductive fluid can serve as a rapidly evolving axis of reproductive isolation through postmating female choice.

O_LIWhen species hybridize, resistance to introgression is presumably due to selection against hybridizing alleles. While many studies have characterized direct selection at these sites, alleles may resist introgression through correlational selection. Here we investigate the role of direct and correlational selection in reducing introgression at the color locus in Ipomoea cordatotriloba. C_LIO_LIWe used recombinant inbred lines that varied in limb color, flower size and sugar concentration to estimate the fitness advantage of the flower color allele via direct and correlational selection. To assess the effect of correlational selection on fitness, we ask if floral size or nectar sugar concentration is correlated with fecundity in pink- but not white-limbed lines. C_LIO_LIWe find no evidence for direct selection on flower color across four fitness components - germination, survival, fecundity, and siring success. Instead, both flower size and sugar concentration significantly correlate with fecundity in pink, but not white limbed lines. As a result, correlational selection on the color allele opposes introgression when recurrent migration is low (<3%). C_LIO_LIThese results demonstrate that correlational, rather than direct, selection is sufficient to resist introgression via hybridization and suggest that correlational selection is an underexplored mechanism to generate resistance to introgression across multiple loci. C_LI

Ecological speciation is now regarded as one of the primary processes by which new species are generated. Adaptive divergence in allopatry begins this process, but it is often unclear when and how mechanisms that promote reproductive isolation, such as assortative mating and selection against hybrids, evolve. Here, we test for evidence of these mechanisms across replicated secondary contact experiments in natural settings. We introduced four to eight allopatric populations of threespine stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus), in both single-ecotype and mixed-ecotype treatments, into nine natural lakes, after which we inferred mating patterns by genotyping the resulting F1 generation. Contrary to expectations from the literature, we found no evidence of assortative mating or partial reproductive isolation among the introduced source populations. Instead, we detected evidence of disassortative mating by source population in three lakes and some evidence of disassortative mating by ecotype in one lake. These mating patterns were both context-dependent and population-dependent, varying substantially across lakes receiving the same source populations, and with some source populations generally displaying greater tendencies for disassortment. The absence of positive assortative mating in any replicate demonstrates that adaptive divergence in allopatry alone might be insufficient to generateassortative mating in many cases, while the possibility of disassortative mating in these contexts poses an additional hurdle on the path toward speciation.

In most species, unmated individuals run the risk of dying with zero fitness. This strong selection on virgin females to mate may also explain why females subsequently remate, despite fitness costs; all that is required is a genetic correlation between virgin and non-virgin mating propensity. Despite being the null model for the evolution and maintenance of polyandry, this hypothesis has received no empirical test. We performed separate quantitative genetic and artificial selection experiments to test the presence of this cross-context genetic correlation in the cow-pea weevil, Callosobruchus maculatus. A quantitative genetic experiment did not find evidence of the hypothesised genetic correlation. However, after 13 generations of artificial selection on virgin mating latency, we found strong evidence for evolutionary divergence in remating latency. Females from lines selected for longer virgin mating latency took approximately twice as long to remate and, were less polyandrous if their virgin mating latency was longer. There was no evidence that females could mate indiscriminately and then trade-up, rather, trading up could only occur if virgin discrimination was present. Selection against virgin death will thus constrain both the evolution of non-virgin discrimination and trading up, increasing rates of polyandry. These findings reveal a genetic correlation between virgin and non-virgin latency to mate suggesting that polyandry may be maintained because of the need to breed.

Variation in warning colouration is common, despite strong positive frequency-dependent selection favouring the most common morph, and may arise from spatially or temporally variable selection or associations with other traits. We investigated the maintenance of warning colour variation in the wood tiger moth, Arctia plantaginis, which shows sexual dimorphism in colouration: two distinct male morphs controlled by a single locus, and continuous variation in female hindwing colour and larval warning signal size. Using whole-genome sequencing of 657 individuals from a laboratory stock derived from a wild polymorphic population, we examined the genetic basis of multiple life-history traits, chemical defence, pheromones, and male activity. We specifically tested for associations with male colour and aimed to identify the genetic basis of female and larval colour variation. We detected separate major-effect loci for female colour and larval signal size, which were different from the male colour locus. Hindwing melanism was the only trait associated with male colour, mapping to a nearby major-effect locus and showing a link to reduced activity at higher temperatures. Female colour was phenotypically correlated with pheromone amount. However, apart from melanism, none of the other traits measured showed an association with any of the loci controlling warning colours and we found no evidence that male colour is part of a supergene or complex co-adapted phenotype. Instead, our results indicate largely independent genetic architectures for warning colours suggesting that variable selection rather than genetic associations may contribute to the maintenance of colour polymorphisms in this species.

Reproductive biology is a key determinant of fitness. State-dependent speciation-extinction methods (SSEs) are often used to associate traits with patterns of diversification. Previously, SSEs have been used within families to investigate the hypothesis that selfing is an evolutionary "dead end." To the best of the authors knowledge, no study has looked across families, which would increase power to more generally test this hypothesis. Here, we examine the impact of 1) mating system and 2) sexual system on diversification across 18 phylogenetically diverse families. We also discuss how more recent advances in SSE models (i.e., "hidden state" and tree-only models) influence our interpretation of these patterns and evaluate how the relationship between mating and sexual systems can be leveraged to gain insight into the impact of reproductive biology on evolutionary outcomes. In this study, we find that the mating system as a trait does not better explain patterns of diversification when compared to null models, but the sexual system often does. We also find family-level heterogeneity in our results, which suggests conclusions drawn from studies on individual families may not be consistent with any broader trend.

The evolution of reproductive isolation is central to speciation, yet the earliest stages of this process remain poorly understood. In particular, it is unclear how rapidly barriers to mating arise during adaptation, whether they accumulate predictably, and how they depend on ecological context. Here, we investigate the evolution of mating efficiency during prolonged asexual adaptation in diploid Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Twelve replicate populations were evolved for 1200 generations in two distinct carbon environments, glucose and galactose, under strictly asexual conditions. At regular intervals, we induced sporulation and quantified mating efficiency using three complementary assays: within-population crosses, crosses between populations evolved in different environments, and crosses between evolved populations and the ancestral strain. We find that mating efficiency evolves during asexual adaptation, with outcomes that depend strongly on the environment. While glucose-evolved populations remain largely stable, galactose-evolved populations exhibit a reversible decline. Overall, changes in mating efficiency are dynamic, heterogeneous, and often transient, with evidence for both intrinsic reductions in mating competence and context-dependent incompatibilities between populations. Together, these results show that asexual adaptation can generate rapid but non-monotonic changes in mating compatibility. Early reductions in mating efficiency are heterogeneous, environment-dependent, and often reversible, and do not accumulate into stable reproductive isolation over the timescale examined. Our findings suggest that the initial stages of divergence are characterized by dynamic and contingent perturbations of reproductive traits, rather than a steady progression toward speciation.

Across animals, variation in adult body size is accompanied by coordinated variation in the size of individual morphological traits. However, the same morphological trait can scale differently with body size depending on what drives the size variation. In Drosophila melanogaster, for example, wing size scales differently with body size when size varies because of developmental nutrition versus developmental temperature. Whether the genetic basis of size plasticity and scaling is shared across different environmental regulators of size remains unclear, but is central to predicting how selection acts on the developmental mechanisms that regulate trait size, plasticity and morphological scaling. Using ~200 isogenic D. melanogaster lineages, we measured wing and leg size across nutritional and thermal treatments. For each lineage, we estimated nutritional and thermal plasticity for both traits, as well as the wing-leg individual-level scaling relationship, or ILSR, generated by each environmental source of size variation. We found extensive genetic variation in both thermal and nutritional plasticity for wings and legs, and in the slope of the ILSR between them. However, a lineages thermal plasticity was genetically uncorrelated with its nutritional plasticity for either trait, and we detected no genetic correlation between the slopes of thermal and nutritional wing-leg ILSRs. We also found no genetic correlation in the slope of nutritional wing-leg ILSRs across temperatures. Thus, the slope of a lineages nutritional ILSR at 17{degrees}C was not predictive of its slope at 25{degrees}C of 28{degrees}C. Nevertheless, the overall pattern of nutritional ILSRs was conserved across temperatures. These results suggest that the genetic architecture of size plasticity and scaling depends on the environmental source of size variation. Consequently, the evolutionary response of scaling to selection in heterogeneous environments may not be predictable from genetic variation measured in any single environment.

Host-parasite coevolution is expected to generate strong selection for susceptibility and infectivity that has the potential to erode genetic variation. Despite this, natural populations often retain extensive genetic variation in these traits. Negative frequency-dependent selection could explain the maintenance of variation since it results in genotype-by-genotype interactions on fitness that, unlike additive genetic variance among hosts and pathogens, is masked from selection and so can remain cryptic. Here we combine coevolutionary modelling with large-scale experimental infection assays to quantify how host-pathogen interactions structure fitness variance in a vertically transmitted virus system, Drosophila melanogaster and sigma virus. Simulations show that coevolution typically erodes additive genetic variance in host and pathogen fitness, concentrating variance in host-virus interaction terms. Consistent with these predictions, experiments spanning 90 host-virus genotype combinations reveal that transmission, viral load and virulence are overwhelmingly governed by host-virus genetic interactions rather than host or virus main (i.e., additive) effects. As a result, neither host resistance alleles nor viral genotypes confer consistently higher fitness across genetic backgrounds. Interactions tend to be sex-specific, further limiting heritable fitness variation. Our results demonstrate that coevolution can substantially mask heritable genetic variation from selection by rendering fitness context dependent. This extensive cryptic genetic variation may be revealed either when ecological or evolutionary conditions shift, or when the process of coevolution itself alters the direction of selection. This demonstrates the need to account for genotype-specific interactions when forecasting evolutionary responses.

Mate preferences are often influenced by the magnitude of sexual signals, which are presumed to indicate underlying aspects of signaller quality. Although the perception of these signals depends on sensory processes, the role of perceptual adaptations and constraints in mate assessment is frequently overlooked. Many sensory systems follow Webers law of proportional processing, where discrimination between signals is based upon their proportional, or relative, difference rather than their absolute difference. Because preference strength varies with relative trait magnitude, Webers law could strongly influence sexual selection, changing the coevolution of traits and preferences. Here, we explore the consequences of Webers law for sexual selection using individual-based models, applying Scalar Utility Theory to mate choice. We investigate the coevolution of male ornaments and female preferences under both Fisherian and good genes scenarios, as well as scrutinizing the sexual selection of multiple ornaments and preferences. Including Webers law in these models either reduced ornament exaggeration, or promoted exaggeration and diversification of ornaments and preferences, depending on the costs of choice and how rapidly female survival decreases when preferences evolve away from the naturally selected optimum. These results highlight the importance of perception and cognitive processing in shaping sexual selection and its evolutionary impacts.

In androdioecious species like Caenorhabditis elegans, where the primary mode of reproduction is self-fertilization, the evolutionary role of males has long puzzled biologists. One proposed benefit of males is the potential to escape inbreeding depression. We tested this by enforcing seven generations of inbreeding across nine C. elegans strains differing in baseline male frequency and measuring competitive relative fitness before and after inbreeding. We then relaxed inbreeding for four generations to assess recovery. We predicted that strains with higher male frequency, and greater opportunity for outcrossing, would exhibit faster recovery once inbreeding was relaxed. Strains varied substantially in their responses with most showing significant fitness declines and partial recovery but neither the magnitude of inbreeding depression nor the extent of recovery correlated with male frequency. These results show that male frequency is a poor predictor of inbreeding responses and does not reliably reflect realized outcrossing or its fitness consequences.

Evolutionary diversity in metabolic rate underlies differences in physiology, morphology, and life history across the tree of life. Cell size has been proposed as an important determinant of metabolic rate. The mechanisms underlying this proposed connection are based on the lower surface area to volume ratios in larger cells. As relative surface area decreases, the cost of maintaining ion gradients across the cell membrane through action of the Na+/K+-ATPase pump are posited to decrease, lowering overall metabolic costs. Despite strong theoretical support for this model, and its incorporation into broader models of life history evolution, empirical measurement of Na+/K+-ATPase activity in species that differ in cell size has been lacking. Here, we study nine species of salamanders of the genus Plethodon that span a large range of cell sizes approaching the animal upper limit. We compare basal cellular respiration rates, relative cost of the Na+/K+-ATPase pump, and maximal mitochondrial respiration rates in liver and heart tissue. Contrary to predictions, we find no support for a relationship between cell size and any of these mitochondrial respiratory variables. We reconcile this surprising result with broader phylogenetic studies showing a lack of correlation between cell size and metabolic rate at the organismal level.

Recombination rate varies within and between individuals. One form of such variations is seen between sexes in dioecious populations, with males typically exhibiting a smaller recombination rate than females. This is true both for sex chromosomes and autosomes (so-called heterochiasmy). Although a large body of theory exists on the role of sex chromosomes in adaptation and population divergence, much less is known about the role of heterochiasmy. Recently, it has been suggested that heterochiasmy can facilitate local adaptation and divergence, but if, and when this is true has not been systematically studied theoretically to date. Here we use Individual-based simulations to assess the effect of sex differences in autosomal recombination rates on the process of divergence and adaptation in populations subject to divergent selection and migration. We found evidence supporting that sex differences in autosomal recombination rate between adaptive loci can facilitate, and especially maintain, divergence, but this is true only under very limited conditions, involving strong selection, high sex-averaged effective recombination rates and relatively high rates of migration compared to the strength of selection. We further found that this effect, when present, is typically weak but is amplified in cases of highly polygenic adaptation in comparison to cases with a few adaptive loci of strong effect. We conclude that, in most cases, sex differences in autosomal recombination rate alone are unlikely to noticeably contribute to the process of adaptation and divergence. Further studies are needed to evaluate their effect in combination with other processes not considered in the present study, such as assortative mating between the alike mates, or recombination suppression in heterozygotes. TeaserIn dioecious populations, recombination rate typically differs between males and females. This is true both for sex chromosomes and autosomes. While much theoretical research has focused on understanding how recombination rate differences in sex chromosomes shape local adaptation and divergence, we lack theoretical knowledge of the potential role of sex differences in autosomal recombination rates. Recombination has a dual role in local adaptation. Strong recombination can effectively purge deleterious alleles, but it can also break apart beneficial allele complexes (and vice versa for weak recombination). Thus, one may expect that in the presence of both strong and weak recombination exhibited by females, and males, respectively, population divergence can be efficiently facilitated. But is this true? Here, we study this question theoretically using computer simulations. Our main finding is that sex differences in autosomal recombination can facilitate divergence, but this effect is typically weak and present only under very stringent conditions.

Eusocial Hymenoptera present the highest known recombination rates among metazoans, which evolved several times independently among bees, ants and wasps. Several hypotheses have been proposed to explain this observation, including stronger selection for recombination caused by coevolving parasites and pathogens, and strong sexual selection among haploid males due to male-biased sex ratios among reproductive individuals. In this article, we explore the effects of haplodiploidy and differential selection between sexes on the evolution of recombination, by analyzing a three-locus model in which selection for recombination stems from negative epistasis between selected loci. Our analytical predictions are compared with the results of individual-based simulations in which deleterious mutations occur along a linear chromosome. Our results show that, at mutation-selection balance for deleterious alleles, increasing the strength of selection against deleterious alleles (due to the effect of male haploidy and/or sexual selection) tends to reduce selection for recombination. However, an increase in the overall magnitude of negative epistasis (which may also be due to male haploidy and/or sexual selection) combined with the fact that recombination only occurs in females may increase selection for recombination substantially. Our model also shows that, in conditions favoring recombination, increasing recombination in meioses leading to parthenogenetic ovules (and male offspring) may yield stronger benefits than in meioses leading to fertilized ovules (and female offspring).

The evolution of alternative male reproductive strategies represents an intriguing evolutionary phenomenon. Divergent strategies are persistently at risk of local extinction or invasion, depending on the suites of traits expressed within and between morphs; hence, understanding the correlational selection that aligns reproductive strategies with behaviour, morphology and physiology is key to understanding the origin and maintenance of genetic polymorphisms. In the polychromatic painted dragon, Ctenophorus pictus, yellow, orange and red morphs are well characterised, but the blue morph has been historically absent from studied populations. Here we document the local distribution, morphology and male-contest interactions in a population where blue males are relatively common. We find that blue males express head colouration after a reaching a threshold body size, and that small blue males can reside in close proximity to other males; patterns consistent with a novel size-dependent conditional tactic within the suite of genetic strategies seen in this species. Condition-dependent, positively allometric throat bibs were non-randomly distributed among male morphs, implicating variation in correlational selection and the genetic architecture of the polymorphism. We were unable to definitively assign a morph that was superior in male competition but found that within morphs, male size was the determinant of competitive success, whilst between morphs it was not. Furthermore, contests between morphs were resolved with less aggression than contests within morphs, supporting the idea that badges resolve conflict, and that the invasion of new colour morphs may be facilitated by negative frequency dependent benefits to novel colour variants. These findings highlight the divergent phenotypic, genetic and selective environments that lead to the diversity of colour morphs.

In odonates, hybridization has been documented in several species pairs, yet the long-term persistence of hybrid phenotypes remains poorly understood, particularly in Neotropical systems. Here, we investigate a putative hybrid zone between Ischnura capreolus and Ischnura cyane, which overlap along an altitudinal gradient in the Colombian Andes. We combined temporal sampling across sympatric and allopatric localities with multilocus genetic analyses and geometric morphometrics of wings and male caudal appendages to evaluate patterns of admixture and phenotypic intermediacy. Morphometric analyses revealed pronounced differentiation between I. capreolus and I. cyane, especially in allopatric populations, whereas individuals from sympatric localities displayed increased morphological overlap and intermediate phenotypes. Genetic analyses based on nuclear and mitochondrial genes identified two main genetic clusters corresponding to the parental species, with evidence of admixture and shared haplotypes in sympatric localities. Patterns of differentiation varied among loci, with mitochondrial markers showing broader haplotype sharing than nuclear loci. Across sympatric localities, morphologically intermediate individuals remained consistently present through time, particularly in Anolaima, where they represented the dominant phenotype across sampling periods. These results support concordant morphological and genetic evidence consistent with persistent hybridization and introgression between I. capreolus and I. cyane in their zone of contact and suggest that incomplete reproductive isolation contributes to the long-term maintenance of admixed phenotypes in this hybrid zone.

Rapid environmental change is exposing organisms to conditions that do not match those under which they evolved, making it increasingly important to understand how genetic variation shapes phenotypic responses to environmental stress. Since most phenotypic traits arise from interactions between genetic variation and the environments experienced throughout an organisms lifetime, understanding the genetic architecture of these interactions is central to predicting how populations will respond to novel environments. While genotype-by-environment interactions (GxE) are well studied in quantitative genetics, identifying specific loci that contribute to environmentally dependent trait expression remains rare. Salmonids already exhibit a wide portfolio of plastic life-history strategies, reflecting adaptation to highly heterogeneous environments, yet it remains unclear whether known major-effect loci involved in life-history regulation also contribute to variation in plastic responses to environmental change. One such major-effect locus is the transcription factor six6, which has been repeatedly associated with variation in age at maturity across multiple populations of rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss). Since maturation timing is closely linked to growth trajectories and patterns of energetic allocation during early development, allelic variation at this locus may also influence growth responses to warming conditions. Here, we test this hypothesis using a common-garden experiment in which 6 months old juvenile rainbow trout were reared under current and warming (+2{degrees}C) temperature regimes. By quantifying genotype-specific reaction norms across environments, we show that six6 genotype contributes to environmentally dependent variation in growth and body composition, with individuals heterozygous for the six6 locus showing a distinct and steeper response to warming relative to homozygotes. These findings provide evidence that a major life-history gene shapes plastic responses to thermal stress in juvenile rainbow trout, with novel implications for how standing genetic variation at in large-effect loci may influence population-level responses to climate warming.

Adaptive phenotypic plasticity can bolster fitness in changing environments, but the extent to which plasticity evolves rapidly, and which forces shape this evolutionary trajectory, is largely unknown. To empirically study the evolution of plasticity we first conducted a replicated field experiment in which Drosophila melanogaster populations adapted to insecticide exposure and a subset of these populations received high diversity assisted gene flow. We then reared individuals from each population across temperature and insecticide treatments in common garden to test the following questions: 1. Has prior selection and rapid adaptation of insecticide resistance led to evolved shifts in plasticity relative to naive populations? 2. Does gene flow from genetically diverse populations contribute to adaptive plasticity evolution relative to gene flow-restricted low diversity populations? Both gene flow and prior evolution of resistance influenced the evolution of plasticity for multiple traits and were often maladaptive for resistant and gene flow-restricted populations, suggesting a trade-off between trait and plasticity evolution. Assisted gene flow minimized maladaptive plasticity potentially through relaxation of underlying epistatic or pleiotropic constraints. Together, these results demonstrate the dynamic interactions between trait evolution, the evolution of plasticity, and forces that shape genetic diversity with implications for conservation of threatened populations.