Back

When crayfish make news, headlines are correct but still misleading

Faulkes, Z.

2024-09-16 scientific communication and education
10.1101/2024.09.07.611802 bioRxiv
Show abstract

Crayfish are well known to many but not often newsworthy, so cases where crayfish are covered in international news provide an example of how science journalism covers a news story about basic research. Headlines have a disproportionately large influence on peoples factual knowledge and perceptions of stories covered in media. I tracked online media coverage of one scientific paper involving marbled crayfish and analyzed the headlines used by the articles. Articles were framed as "news," but almost no headlines contained "new" facts that first appeared in the target scientific paper. The fact that appeared in the most headlines (that marbled crayfish reproduce by cloning) was over a decade old. Headlines misled readers into thinking a "breakthrough" was made by one team, rather than showing incremental advances by many teams of researchers over years.

Matching journals

The top 5 journals account for 50% of the predicted probability mass.

1
PeerJ
◐ 308 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
13.2%
2
Ecology and Evolution
○ 267 papers in training set
Top 0.2%
12.2%
3
eLife
● 5828 papers in training set
Top 9%
10.0%
4
F1000Research
○ 88 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
9.9%
5
PLOS ONE
● 5266 papers in training set
Top 21%
8.1%
50% of probability mass above
6
FACETS
● 14 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
6.9%
7
Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
● 393 papers in training set
Top 2%
4.1%
8
Animals
○ 23 papers in training set
Top 0.2%
3.3%
9
Royal Society Open Science
● 214 papers in training set
Top 1%
3.3%
10
Frontiers in Marine Science
○ 62 papers in training set
Top 0.4%
2.5%
11
Biological Conservation
○ 46 papers in training set
Top 0.5%
2.2%
12
Heliyon
○ 152 papers in training set
Top 2%
2.2%
13
Frontiers in Integrative Neuroscience
○ 15 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
2.2%
14
Conservation Biology
○ 17 papers in training set
Top 0.2%
2.2%
15
eneuro
● 439 papers in training set
Top 4%
1.7%
16
Ecological Informatics
○ 33 papers in training set
Top 0.5%
1.2%
17
Pigment Cell & Melanoma Research
○ 11 papers in training set
Top 0.2%
1.2%
18
Wellcome Open Research
○ 67 papers in training set
Top 2%
0.9%
19
Frontiers in Veterinary Science
○ 32 papers in training set
Top 0.6%
0.9%
20
ICES Journal of Marine Science
◐ 11 papers in training set
Top 0.2%
0.9%
21
American Journal of Primatology
○ 20 papers in training set
Top 0.3%
0.6%
22
Frontiers in Psychology
○ 56 papers in training set
Top 2%
0.6%
23
Scientific Reports
○ 3612 papers in training set
Top 77%
0.6%
24
PLOS Biology
● 486 papers in training set
Top 13%
0.6%