Back

Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences

The Royal Society

All preprints, ranked by how well they match Proceedings of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences's content profile, based on 15 papers previously published here. The average preprint has a 0.01% match score for this journal, so anything above that is already an above-average fit. Older preprints may already have been published elsewhere.

1
Scaling rules for pandemics: Estimating infected fraction from identified cases for the SARS-CoV-2 Pandemic

Ma, M.; Zsolway, M.; Tarafder, A.; Bhanot, G.

2022-09-06 health informatics 10.1101/2022.09.05.22279599 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
11.8%
Show abstract

Using a modified form of the SIR model, we show that, under general conditions, all pandemics exhibit certain scaling rules. Using only daily data for symptomatic, confirmed cases, these scaling rules can be used to estimate: (i) reff, the effective pandemic R-parameter; (ii) ftot, the fraction of exposed individuals that were infected (symptomatic and asymptomatic); (iii) Leff, the effective latency, the average number of days an infected individual is able to infect others in the pool of susceptible individuals; and (iv) , the probability of infection per contact between infected and susceptible individuals. We validate the scaling rules using an example and then apply our method to estimate reff, ftot, Leff and for the first phase of the SARS-Cov-2, Covid-19 pandemic for several countries where there was a well separated first peak in identified infected daily cases after the outbreak of the pandemic in early 2020. Our results are general and can be applied to any pandemic.

2
A Nonlinear Biomechanical Model for Prognostic Analysis of Clavicle Fractures

Chen, Y.

2026-04-09 bioengineering 10.64898/2026.04.06.716697 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
9.8%
Show abstract

Clavicle fractures often exhibit markedly different clinical outcomes: some patients recover acceptable function despite shortening or displacement, whereas others with apparently similar deformity develop persistent pain, functional loss, or poor healing. To explain this distinction, we propose a minimal nonlinear mechanical model for prognostic analysis of clavicle fractures. The model describes the interaction between fracture-related shortening and compensatory shoulder-girdle posture through a reduced equilibrium equation incorporating stiffness, geometric nonlinearity, and shortening-posture coupling. Within this framework, we analyze equilibrium branches, local stability, and the emergence of critical thresholds. We show that post-fracture destabilization can be interpreted as a fold bifurcation, while more complex parameter dependence gives rise to cusp-type structures and multistability. These bifurcation mechanisms provide a mathematical explanation for sudden deterioration after injury or treatment, as well as for strong inter-individual variability. We further introduce an optimization principle based on a utility functional to guide treatment planning. The analysis predicts that the optimal safe correction should lie strictly below the bifurcation threshold, thereby generating a natural safety margin. Although the model is simplified and has not yet been calibrated against patient data, it nevertheless provides a theoretical framework for understanding why fracture prognosis may deteriorate abruptly near critical mechanical conditions and offers a dynamical-systems interpretation of empirical treatment thresholds used in clinical practice.

3
Avoiding COVID-19: Aerosol Guidelines

Evans, M.

2020-05-27 infectious diseases 10.1101/2020.05.21.20108894 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
9.0%
Show abstract

AO_SCPLOWBSTRACTC_SCPLOWThe COVID-19 pandemic has brought into sharp focus the need to understand respiratory virus transmission mechanisms. In preparation for an anticipated influenza pandemic, a substantial body of literature has developed over the last few decades showing that the short-range aerosol route is an important, though often neglected transmission path. We develop a simple mathematical model for COVID-19 transmission via aerosols, apply it to known outbreaks, and present quantitative guidelines for ventilation and occupancy in the workplace.

4
A Thin-Film Lubrication Model for Biofilm Expansion Under Strong Adhesion

Tam, A. K. Y.; Harding, B.; Green, J. E. F.; Balasuriya, S.; Binder, B. J.

2021-11-19 biophysics 10.1101/2021.11.16.468738 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
7.8%
Show abstract

Understanding microbial biofilm growth is important to public health, because biofilms are a leading cause of persistent clinical infections. In this paper, we develop a thin-film model for microbial biofilm growth on a solid substratum to which it adheres strongly. We model biofilms as two-phase viscous fluid mixtures of living cells and extracellular fluid. The model tracks the movement, depletion, and uptake of nutrients explicitly, and incorporates cell proliferation via a nutrient-dependent source term. Notably, our thin-film reduction is two-dimensional and includes the vertical dependence of cell volume fraction. Numerical solutions show that this vertical dependence is weak for biologically-feasible parameters, reinforcing results from previous models in which this dependence was neglected. We exploit this weak dependence by writing and solving a simplified one-dimensional model that is computationally more efficient than the full model. We use both the one and two-dimensional models to predict how model parameters affect expansion speed and biofilm thickness. This analysis reveals that expansion speed depends on cell proliferation, nutrient availability, cell-cell adhesion on the upper surface, and slip on the biofilm-substratum interface. Our numerical solutions provide a means to qualitatively distinguish between the extensional flow and lubrication regimes, and quantitative predictions that can be tested in future experiments.

5
Linked Exposures Across Databases (LEAD): An exposure data aggregation framework to facilitate clinical exposure review

Samuel, I. B.; Pollin, K.; Tschida, S.; Lu, C.; Prisco, M.; Forsten, R.; Ortiz, J.; Barrett, J.; Reinhard, M.; Costanzo, M.

2024-03-02 health informatics 10.1101/2024.03.01.24303567 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
7.2%
Show abstract

Understanding the health outcomes of military exposures is a critical effort for Veterans, their health care team, and national leaders. Veterans Affairs providers receive reports of military exposure related concerns from 43% of Veterans. Understanding the causal influences of environmental exposures on health is a complex task advancement in exposure science and may require interpreting multiple data sources; particularly when exposure pathways and multi-exposure interactions are ill-defined, as is the case for complex and emerging military service-related exposures. Thus, there is a need to standardize clinically meaningful exposure metrics from different data sources to guide clinicians and researchers with a consistent model for investigating and communicating exposure risk profiles. The Linked Exposures Across Databases (LEAD) framework provides a unifying model for characterizing exposure from different exposure datatypes and databases with a focus on providing clinically relevant exposure metrics. Application of LEAD is demonstrated through comparison of different military exposure data sources: Veteran Military Occupational and Environmental Exposure Assessment Tool (VMOAT), Individual Longitudinal Exposure Record (ILER) database and a military incident report database, the Explosive Ordnance Disposal Information Management System (EODIMS). This cohesive method for evaluating military exposures leverages established information with new sources of data and has the potential to influence how military exposure data is integrated into exposure health care and investigational models.

6
Understanding community level influences on COVID-19 prevalence in England: New insights from comparison over time and space

Joshi, C.; Ali, A.; O'Connor, T.; Chen, L.; Jahanshahi, K.

2022-04-14 health informatics 10.1101/2022.04.14.22273759 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
6.8%
Show abstract

Understanding and monitoring the major influences on SARS-CoV-2 prevalence is essential to inform policy making and devise appropriate packages of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs). Through evaluating community level influences on the prevalence of SARS-CoV-2 infection and their spatiotemporal variations in England, this study aims to provide some insights into the most important risk parameters. We used spatial clusters developed in Jahanshahi and Jin, 2021 as geographical areas with distinct land use and travel patterns. We also segmented our data by time periods to control for changes in policies or development of the disease over the course of the pandemic. We then used multivariate linear regression to identify influences driving infections within the clusters and to compare the variations of those between the clusters. Our findings demonstrate the key roles that workplace and commuting modes have had on some of the sections of the working population after accounting for several interrelated influences including mobility and vaccination. We found communities of workers in care homes and warehouses and to a lesser extent textile and ready meal industries and those who rely more on public transport for commuting tend to carry a higher risk of infection across all residential area types and time periods.

7
The "osteostat": a theory of bone mechanosensing and setpoint adaptation based on osteocytes

Pauchard, Y.; Buenzli, P. R.

2026-06-25 bioengineering 10.64898/2026.06.23.734120 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
6.8%
Show abstract

The osteocyte network in bone is believed to play an important role for how bone tissues sense and respond to mechanical stimulation. Yet, bone adaptation to mechanical loads is often conceptualised as a simple response to mechanical stimuli, such as Wolffs law, which is based on mechanical variables only and takes no account of the cellular basis of mechanosensation. Wolffs law presumes the existence of a reference mechanical stimulus, the mechanical setpoint, above which bone is consolidated, and under which bone is removed. In this paper, we develop a theory of bone tissue sensing and adaptation based on osteocytes to provide new understanding of the role played by osteocyte signals in mechanical adaptation. In this theory, the mechanical setpoint of Frosts mechanostat is explicitly embodied as osteocyte properties involved in mechanotransduction. The mechanical setpoint is allowed to adapt due to the replacement of osteocytes during remodelling, making the setpoint space and time dependent. We propose a mathematical model to implement this new theory of bone adapation and present numerical simulations of this model to explore how mechanobiological response curves (effective Wolffs laws) are modulated by setpoint adaptation during remodelling. By accounting for varying osteocyte populations within bone tissue, we explore bone adaptation under osteocyte disruptions, which is particularly relevant to age-related bone loss. Our model suggests that biological disruptions of remodelling balance cannot always be compensated by mechanical feedback, and that setpoint adaptation during remodelling may have significant observable consequences, such as hysteresis in bone response signatures that resemble lazy zones.

8
A Statistical Model for Quantifying the Needed Duration of Social Distancing for the COVID-19 Pandemic

Rakocz, N.; Fu, B.; Halperin, E.; Sankararaman, S.

2020-07-03 health informatics 10.1101/2020.05.30.20117796 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
6.8%
Show abstract

Understanding the effectiveness of strategies such as social distancing is a central question in attempts to control the COVID-19 pandemic. A key unknown in social distancing strategies is the duration of time for which such strategies are needed. Answering this question requires an accurate model of the transmission trajectory. A challenge in fitting such a model is the limited COVID-19 case data available from a given location. To overcome this challenge, we propose fitting a model of SARS-CoV-2 transmission jointly across multiple locations. We apply the model to COVID-19 case data from Spain, UK, Germany, France, Denmark, and New York to estimate the distribution for the time needed for social distancing to end to range from May 2020 to July 2021 (95% credible interval), where the median date is October, 2020. Our method is not specific to COVID-19, and it can also be applied to future pandemics.

9
Derivation of a Time-Dependent Model for Long-Term Cortical Bone Adaptation

Prasad, J.

2025-09-04 bioengineering 10.1101/2025.08.31.673332 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
6.7%
Show abstract

This work attempts to derive long-term, time-dependent cortical bone adaptation to mechanical loading. Linear control theory is used to model the adaptation process, with the stimulus defined in terms of dissipation energy density. The newly adapted area is expressed as a function of the stimulus in the form of a differential equation, which is analyzed to obtain closed-form solutions. The study explores different possibilities, such as varying the order of differential equations (including fractional order) and examining different types of responses, e.g., critically damped and overdamped. Such model diversity will help identify the most appropriate formulation that fits experimental data.

10
A mathematical model of osteocyte network control of bone mechanical adaptation

Mehrpooya, A.; Challis, V. J.; Buenzli, P. R.

2025-11-10 bioengineering 10.1101/2025.10.10.681578 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
6.7%
Show abstract

The osteocyte network embedded in bone tissues plays a central role in the control of bone adaptation to mechanical loads and micro-damage repair. However, much remains to be understood about the precise mechanisms by which the osteocyte network regulates bone formation and bone resorption based on the propagation of biochemical signals emitted in response to mechanical stimulus. In this work, we propose a simple one-dimensional computational model of bone mechanical adaptation based on the propagation of signalling molecules through a dynamic osteocyte network. The osteocyte network is extended during bone formation, and reduced during bone resorption, which affects the generation and propagation of the signalling molecules to the bone surface. We explore how this osteocyte-based model of bone mechanosensation and mechanoresponse gives rise to effective Wolffs laws, in which overloaded bone is consolidated and underloaded bone is removed. We find that the discrete addition and removal of osteocytes significantly affects signalling molecules propagating to the bone surface and leads to new bone adaptation behaviours compared to earlier models, including partial bone recovery following an unloading and reloading cycle, and the emergence of a minimum threshold of mechanical stress below which all bone is resorbed. While many extensions of this mathematical model are possible, it provides a first illustration of how the osteocyte network could act as a dynamic embedded control network for bone adaptation to mechanical loads.

11
Elasticity of a three-dimensional cell vertex model of epithelia

Terada, K.; Kondo, Y.

2026-05-18 biophysics 10.64898/2026.05.15.725329 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
6.6%
Show abstract

Mechanical properties of epithelial tissues play essential roles in morphogenesis and physiological function. In this study, we analytically derived the in-plane bulk modulus, shear modulus, and Poissons ratio of a three-dimensional cell vertex model of epithelial monolayers. We showed that the model can robustly reproduce a near-zero in-plane Poissons ratio, a mechanical feature reported in cultured epithelial tissues. Numerical simulations further confirmed that the theoretically predicted Poissons ratio accurately describes the response of the model under finite, biologically relevant strains. In addition, the model exhibits not only morphological bistability between squamous-like and columnar-like states, but also mechanical bistability characterized by distinct elastic responses. Together, these results provide a minimal three-dimensional framework that links cell-scale mechanical interactions and epithelial morphology to tissue-scale elastic properties.

12
Investigating a Relation between Amyloid Beta Plaque Burden and Accumulated Neurotoxicity Caused by Amyloid Beta Oligomers

Kuznetsov, A. V.

2026-04-10 biophysics 10.64898/2026.04.07.717091 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
6.2%
Show abstract

Alzheimers disease (AD) is characterized by the accumulation of amyloid-{beta} (A{beta}), yet the specific link between plaque burden and cognitive decline remains a subject of intense investigation. This paper presents a mathematical model that simulates the coupled dynamics of A{beta} monomers, soluble oligomers, and fibrillar species in the brain tissue. By modifying existing moment equations to include a dedicated conservation equation for A{beta} monomers, the model explores how various microscopic processes, such as primary nucleation, surface-catalyzed secondary nucleation, fibril elongation, and fragmentation, contribute to macroscopic disease progression. Central to this study is the concept of "accumulated neurotoxicity" as a surrogate marker of biological age, defined as the time-integrated concentration of soluble A{beta} oligomers. Unlike plaque burden, accumulated neurotoxicity cannot be reversed, and the harm it causes depends critically on the sequence of events that produced it. Numerical results demonstrate that while plaque burden and neurotoxicity both increase over time, their relationship is non-linear and highly sensitive to the efficiency of protein degradation machinery. Specifically, impaired degradation leads to a rapid advancement of biological age relative to calendar age. The model further identifies oligomer dissociation and fibril fragmentation as potential protective mechanisms that can counterintuitively reduce neurotoxic burden by diverting monomers away from the soluble oligomer pool. These findings provide a quantitative framework for understanding why individuals with similar plaque burdens may experience vastly different cognitive outcomes, underscoring the importance of targeting soluble oligomers early in therapeutic interventions.

13
Emergence of travelling wave patterns in resource-mediated tissue competition

Brinas-Pascual, N.; Alarcon, T.; Calvo, J.; Guerrero, P.; Oliver-Bonafoux, R.

2026-08-19 biophysics 10.64898/2026.08.11.744236 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
6.1%
Show abstract

The study of tissue dynamics has been stimulated during the last decades thanks to the use of quantitative descriptions, with the development of several theoretical and computational frameworks, many of them revolving around the notion of reaction-diffusion systems, eventually with additional structure variables beyond time and space. The use of structure variables can accommodate phenotypic traits. In this work, we study a family of competition models, where a given population depends on a resource (e.g. oxygen) and several populations are competing for it. Our quantitative description incorporates phenotypic traits and heterogeneity at the level of cell cycle variations, which influence replication rates via oxygen consumption. This enables us to replicate the fitness of specific subpopulations to environmental conditions (e.g. oxygen shortage or external influences). Using numerical simulations, we show that such models display dynamical pattern formation in the form of coupled travelling wave profiles that expand or retreat at the same wave speed. The full theoretical analysis of such dynamics is quite involved; to circumvent this difficulty, we introduce a quasi-stationary approximation for the resource dynamics. We find that this approximation can reproduce the overall behaviour very accurately, with the additional benefit of allowing theoretical treatment of the reduced model. In this way, we provide estimates on the wave speed which are numerically shown to be robust across a wide range of macroscopic parameters of the full model. The wave speeds are thus found to depend strongly on the proliferation rate of the fittest population, resembling a winner-takes-all dynamics.

14
How cancer-associated fibroblasts promote T-cell exclusion in human lung tumors: a physical perspective

Ackermann, J.; Bernard, C.; Sirven, P.; Salmon, H.; Fraldi, M.; Ben Amar, M.

2024-07-29 biophysics 10.1101/2024.01.16.575824 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
6.1%
Show abstract

The tumor stroma is a tissue composed primarily of extracellular matrix, fibroblasts, immune cells, and vasculature. Its structure and functions, such as nutrient support and waste removal, are altered during malignancy. Tumor cells transform fibroblasts into cancer-associated fibroblasts, which have important immunosuppressive activity on which growth, invasion, and metastasis depend. These activated fibroblasts prevent immune cell infiltration into the tumor nest, thereby promoting cancer progression and inhibiting T-cell-based immunotherapy. To understand these complex interactions, we measure the density of different cell types in the stroma using immunohistochemistry techniques on tumor samples from lung cancer patients. We incorporate these data, and also known information on cell proliferation rates and relevant biochemical interactions, into a minimal dynamical system with few parameters. A spatio-temporal approach to the inhomogeneous environment explains the cell distribution and fate of lung carcinomas. The model reproduces that cancer-associated fibroblasts act as a barrier to tumor growth, but also reduce the efficiency of the immune response. The final outcome depends on the parameter values for each patient and leads to either tumor invasion, persistence, or eradication as a result of the interplay between cancer cell growth, T-cell cytotoxic activity, and fibroblast attraction, activation, and spatial dynamics. Our conclusion is that a wide spectrum of scenarios exists as a result of the competition between the characteristic times of cancer cell growth and the activity rates of the other species. Nevertheless, distinct trajectories and patterns allow quantitative predictions that may help in the selection of new therapies and personalized protocols. We conclude with different options for further modeling. O_FIG O_LINKSMALLFIG WIDTH=200 HEIGHT=118 SRC="FIGDIR/small/575824v3_ufig1.gif" ALT="Figure 1"> View larger version (44K): org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@156ac4forg.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@14a9a19org.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@cafebeorg.highwire.dtl.DTLVardef@11aa3bf_HPS_FORMAT_FIGEXP M_FIG O_FLOATNOGraphical AbstractC_FLOATNO C_FIG

15
Fuzzy Linear Programming for Military Medical Logistics: Optimizing Triage and Evacuation Under Uncertainty

Dadashkarimi, M.

2025-07-31 health informatics 10.1101/2025.07.30.25332461 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
5.5%
Show abstract

Withdrawal StatementThe authors have withdrawn their manuscript owing to errors in the experimental design that affect the integrity of the results. Therefore, the authors do not wish this work to be cited as reference for the project. If you have any questions, please contact the corresponding author

16
A projection model of COVID-19 pandemic for Belgium

Ruzhansky, M.; Tokmagambetov, N.; Torebek, B.

2020-06-03 health informatics 10.1101/2020.05.31.20118406 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
5.5%
Show abstract

We consider a simple model for the COVID-19 pandemic to analyse the relative effectiveness of several stages of the lockdown in Belgium, as well as of several phases of its relaxation. We also make a future projection of different types of measures relative to different stages of the already experienced lockdown.

17
A mathematical model of curvature controlled tissue growth incorporating mechanical cell interactions

Kuba, S.; Simpson, M. J.; Buenzli, P. R.

2026-03-12 biophysics 10.64898/2026.03.10.710423 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
5.4%
Show abstract

Biological tissues grow at rates that depend on the geometry of the supporting tissue substrate. In this study, we present a novel discrete mathematical model for simulating biological tissue growth in a range of geometries. The discrete model is deterministic and tracks the evolution of the tissue interface by representing it as a chain of individual cells that interact mechanically and simultaneously generate new tissue material. To describe the collective behaviour of cells, we derive a continuum limit description of the discrete model leading to a reaction-diffusion partial differential equation governing the evolution of cell density along the evolving interface. In the continuum limit, the mechanical properties of discrete cells are directly linked to their collective diffusivity, and spatial constraints introduce curvature dependence that is not explicitly incorporated in the discrete model. Numerical simulations of both the discrete and continuum models reproduce the smoothing behaviour observed experimentally with minimal discrepancies between the models. The discrete model offers further individual-level details, including cell trajectory data, for any restoring force law and initial geometry. Where applicable, we discuss how the discrete model and its continuum description can be used to interpret existing experimental observations.

18
Optimal Control For A Crossover Cholera Mathematical Model Using Fractal (Variable-Fractional) {Psi}-Caputo Derivative With Nonstandard Kernel

AL-Mekhlafi, S. M.; Bonyah, E.

2025-04-01 health informatics 10.1101/2025.03.31.25324982 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
5.4%
Show abstract

This paper introduces an optimal control strategy for choleras crossover mathematical model. The proposed model integrates {Psi}-Caputo fractal variable-order derivatives, fractal fractional-order derivatives, and integer-order derivatives across three distinct time intervals, utilizing a simple non-standard kernel function {Psi}(t). A comprehensive stability analysis of the models steady states is conducted. The models results are compared with real-world data from the cholera outbreak in Yemen. Following this, an optimal control problem is formulated within the crossover framework. To numerically solve the resulting optimality system, a discretized non-standard -finite difference method is developed. Numerical simulations and comparative studies are presented to demonstrate the methods applicability and the efficiency of the approximation approach. The key finding of this study highlights that the crossover-controlled system proves to be the most effective approach for mitigating and controlling the spread of cholera.

19
Effect of ambient fluid rheology on oscillatory instabilities in filament-motor systems

Mishra, A.; Tamayo, J.; Gopinath, A.

2022-03-17 biophysics 10.1101/2022.03.14.484323 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
5.3%
Show abstract

Filaments and filament bundles such as microtubules or actin interacting with molecular motors such as dynein or myosin constitute a common motif in biology. Synthetic mimics, examples being artificial muscles and reconstituted active networks, also feature active filaments. A common feature of these filament-motor systems is the emergence of stable oscillations as a collective dynamic response. Here, using a combination of classical linear stability analysis and non-linear numerical solutions, we study the dynamics of a minimal filament-motor system immersed in model viscoelastic fluids. We identify steady states, test the linear stability of these states, derive analytical stability boundaries, and investigate emergent oscillatory solutions and their properties. We show that the interplay between motor activity, aggregate elasticity and fluid viscoelasticity allows for stable oscillations or limit cycles to bifurcate from steady states. For highly viscous Newtonian media, frequencies at onset decay with viscosity as [Formula]. In viscoelastic fluids that have the same viscosity as the Newtonian fluid but additionally allow for temporary energy storage, emergent limit cycles are associated with higher frequencies. The magnitude of the increase in the frequency depends on motor mechanochemistry and the interplay between fluid relaxation time-scales and time-scales associated with motor binding and unbinding. Our results suggest that stability and dynamical response in filamentous active systems may be controlled by tailoring the rheology of the ambient environment.

20
A study of hyperelastic continuum models for isotropic athermal fibrous networks

Song, D.; Oberai, A.; Janmey, P.

2022-06-29 biophysics 10.1101/2022.06.28.497976 medRxiv
Top 0.1%
5.3%
Show abstract

Many biological materials contain fibrous protein networks as their main structural components. Understanding the mechanical properties of such networks is important for creating biomimicking materials for cell and tissue engineering, and for developing novel tools for detecting and diagnosing disease. In this work, we develop continuum models for isotropic, athermal fibrous networks by combining a single-fiber model that describes the axial response of individual fibers, with network models that assemble individual fiber properties into overall network behavior. In particular, we consider four different network models, including the affine, three-chain, eight-chain, and micro-sphere models, which employ different assumptions about network structure and kinematics. We systematically investigate the ability of these models to describe the mechanical response of athermal collagen and fibrin networks by comparing model predictions with experimental data. We test how each model captures network behavior under three different loading conditions: uniaxial tension, simple shear, and combined tension and shear. We find that the affine and three-chain models can accurately describe both the axial and shear behavior, whereas the eight-chain and micro-sphere models fail to capture the shear response, leading to an unphysical zero shear moduli at infinitesimal strains. Our study is the first to systematically investigate the applicability of popular network models for describing the macroscopic behavior of athermal fibrous networks, offering insights for selecting efficient models that can be used for large-scale, finite-element simulations of athermal networks.