Quantifying the Pharyngeal Wall Thickness on Modified Barium Swallow Studies: A Scoping Review and Reliability Study

Purpose: Posterior pharyngeal wall (PPW) thickening is a common structural manifestation of treatment-related internal lymphedema in patients with head and neck cancer and can be evaluated using lateral videofluoroscopic images acquired during modified barium swallow (MBS) studies. However, no standardized method currently exists for quantitative measurement. Methods: This two-phase methodological study first conducted a scoping review to characterize existing approaches to PPW thickness measurement and identify the principal factors contributing to variation in PPW thickness measurement. Eight studies were identified with variation observed across these measurement factors. An empirical reliability study was then performed using 107 MBS studies from 93 Head and Neck Cancer patients. Two independent raters annotated 10 anatomical landmarks on pre-swallow and post-swallow resting frames, and a computer-assisted algorithm quantitatively generated seven candidate PPW thickness measurements based on different vertebral reference points and measurement directions. Reliability was assessed intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs). Results: Inter-rater reliability was highest for the measurement originating from the midpoint of C3 and extending perpendicular to the anterior C3 surface (ICC, 0.78; 95% CI, 0.72-0.83). Among the normalization references, C2-C4 vertebral length demonstrated greater reliability than C3 vertebral length, with an ICC of 0.88 (95% CI, 0.85-0.91). No significant differences were observed between pre-swallow and post-swallow PPW thickness measurements across the evaluated approaches. Conclusions: These findings provide a methodological foundation for more standardized and reliable quantification of PPW thickness, with potential to expand the role of MBS from the functional evaluation of swallowing to include quantitative characterization of pharyngeal structural abnormalities.