What tools do men need to make an informed decision about germline genetic testing for prostate cancer: A qualitative and survey study

BACKGROUND: Prostate cancer (PrCa) is the most commonly diagnosed cancer in men in many countries and is the most heritable of the common cancers. Precision medicine approaches to disease management are not routinely available to most men, yet we know that germline genetic testing can help identify those at high-risk of developing advanced or lethal disease and can influence selection of therapeutics. An integral part of healthcare delivery design is the inclusion of patients/consumers in the development of frameworks for managing health interventions that are tailored to meet their needs. METHODS: In Phase I, we undertook focus group discussions with men previously diagnosed with PrCa (n=20), to determine their opinions, perceptions and expectations of germline genetic testing for PrCa. Focus groups were tape-recorded, transcribed verbatim, coded and then thematically analysed using NVivo. In Phase II, themes were then used to design and development a Precision Medicine in Prostate Cancer Information Toolkit, which was reviewed by patients (n=14), their carers/family members (n=4) and healthcare providers (n=14). RESULTS: In Phase I, knowledge about precision medicine and genetic testing was generally low. The strongest motivation for undertaking testing was to identify family members' risk levels (n=7), and the biggest concern pertained to insurance discrimination (n=5). Phase II data revealed that generally healthcare providers (n=8) found the purpose of the toolkit to be clearer than patients (n=5). Though, patients found the task of imagining the usefulness of the toolkit at the time of diagnosis or beforehand when assessing genetic risk, quite difficult. Participants highlighted that information regarding life insurance, implications for their family and costs associated with testing were of concern. CONCLUSIONS: This study has revealed critical knowledge gaps, preferred communication/support needs, and concerns/risks associated with germline genetic testing in PrCa. Concerns pertaining to family members and insurance discrimination are obvious topics that need to be addressed. Our toolkit may be helpful in addressing knowledge gaps, but further testing is needed to ensure its accessibility across literary and cultural contexts.