Beyond diversity: A whole system view of vegetation's control of erosion

Streambank erosion degrades both terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems, and riparian buffers are among the most widely used tools to control it. Yet most of what is known about how riparian vegetation controls erosion comes from one or two-species systems, which overlook the diversity of riparian communities and species interactions (competition and facilitation) that may shape the root systems that bind soil. We used a streambank mesocosm experiment to test whether plant species richness alters root traits, and whether root traits and species interactions reduce erosion. We established 85 mesocosms ranging from unvegetated controls to six-species polycultures, measured root biomass, length, volume, and diameter, quantified species interactions with relative yield totals (RYT), and measured erosion rate with a jet erosion test. Vegetated mesocosms eroded significantly less than unvegetated controls (t = 4.05, p = 0.023). Richness did not affect most root traits, although mean root diameter decreased as richness increased ({beta} = -0.0225, p = 0.047). RYT ranged from competition (RYT < 1) to facilitation (RYT >1), yet neither interactions nor any root trait was directly associated with erosion rate. However, RYT was negatively associated with soil moisture ({beta} = -0.196, p = 0.010). Piecewise structural equation models showed that erosion was best explained by a pathway linking species presence, root length, and soil moisture (AIC = 39.27; Fisher's C = 11.27, df = 12, p = 0.506). Panicum virgatum increased root length, whereas Lolium multiflorum and Echinochloa crus-galli reduced it; longer roots were associated with drier soil (standardized {beta} = -0.31, p = 0.005), and wetter soils eroded more slowly (standardized {beta} = -0.39, p < 0.001). Which species were present mattered more than how many, and plants were linked to erosion through soil moisture rather than root traits alone. Species selection for riparian buffers may need to consider effects on soil moisture as well as rooting extent, particularly as droughts followed by intense storms become more common under a changing climate.