More fruits, more frugivores, but not necessarily more visits: findings from two tropical plant-avian frugivore communities

Fruit resource availability can influence the local abundance of avian frugivores through bottom-up regulation, but whether greater resource availability translates into higher visitation rates to fruiting trees remains poorly understood. Greater fruit availability could increase visitation by supporting larger frugivore populations, or reduce visitation to individual trees if increases in frugivore abundance are not proportionate to those in fruit availability or if frugivores distribute their foraging effort. Understanding these relationships can provide insights into the relative role of abundance and trait-based mechanisms in structuring plant-frugivore communities. We compared fruit availability, avian frugivore abundance, and frugivore visitation rates on fruiting trees across two protected wet tropical forest sites: Anamalai Tiger Reserve in the Western Ghats and Namdapha Tiger Reserve in the Eastern Himalaya. Specifically, we quantified the availability of bird-consumed fruits across one-ha patches, estimated local abundances of major frugivore groups, and tested whether visitation rates on individual fruiting trees were related to frugivore abundance, body mass, and degree of frugivory. We found that small-seeded fruit availability was significantly higher in Anamalai than in Namdapha. Local abundances of several relatively small-bodied frugivore groups, including bulbuls, barbets, fairy-bluebirds, and mynas, were also higher in Anamalai. However, visitation rates of several frugivore groups on individual fruiting trees were higher in Namdapha. Visitation rates across all avian frugivore species were associated with frugivore abundances only in Anamalai, and not associated with body mass or degree of frugivory in either site. Thus, although greater fruit availability was likely associated with higher frugivore abundance, this increase in abundance did not consistently translate into higher visitation rates at individual fruiting trees, which provides some support for the resource dilution hypothesis. Our results highlight the importance of considering fruit resource availability and frugivore abundance when examining variation in tropical plant-frugivore interactions.