Metrics matter: Modelling plant-frugivore networks in a tropical dry forest ecosystem

Arboreal camera trapping is an emerging remote sensing tool for building plant-frugivore interaction networks with enormous potential to provide new insights into seed dispersal as an eco-evolutionary process. Interaction data derived from camera trap videos broadly falls into two categories: visitation, indicating the presence of an animal in a tree, and intake, indicating true fruit consumption. These linked approximations of seed dispersal may or may not provide distinct sets of information, shaping our understanding of network dynamics, yet the extent to which emergent network structure depends on variable choice is unknown. To address this gap, we deployed camera traps in the canopy of 21 plant species in the Costa Rican tropical dry forest, an endangered biome with sparse community-wide plant-frugivore interaction data. Our objectives were: 1) Quantify plant-frugivore network structure in the tropical dry forest via network, group, and species-level metrics; and 2) Compare metrics between visitation and intake networks. We find strong structural patterns of low connectance, low nestedness, high modularity, and low niche overlap that differ significantly from null expectations in the same direction in both networks. The visitation network exhibited significantly greater modularity & species degree than the intake network, while the intake network exhibited significantly greater plant niche overlap than the visitation network. These findings suggest that the likelihood of consuming fruit on camera differs across species, which may have downstream consequences on other emerging metric estimations. Researchers seeking to build quantitative plant-frugivore networks should therefore consider visitation and intake variables in concert when relying on camera trap data. This work provides foundational plant-frugivore interaction data for a critically endangered biome and enhances our understanding of camera trapping as a remote sensing tool in frugivory and seed dispersal research.