Clustering without clusters: the meta-criterion and centroid reliability mistake continuous dynamics for discrete states
von Wegner, F.; Hermann, G.
Show abstract
Microstate analysis starts with clustering and the meta-criterion is a heuristic to find an optimum cluster number. We address the following questions: (i) what number is found for non-cluster-forming dynamical systems, (ii) do centroids fall in random attractor regions, (iii) do EEG topographies form clusters or a single connected structure in sensor space? We find that (i) the meta-criterion suggests spurious optimal cluster numbers (4-8) with high confidence on different attractor geometries, (ii) cluster centroids reliably fall in the same attractor regions, (iii) topological analysis of dynamical systems and resting-state EEG suggests that all form a single connected structure in their respective phase space, not clusters. We conclude that the meta-criterion should be used with caution and its results should not be taken as representing a ground truth. Cluster numbers deviating from the meta-criterion should not be discarded. A more far-reaching implication is that evidence for the existence of clusters in resting-state EEG data is still lacking. Microstate clustering may correspond to the partitioning of a single connected structure.
Matching journals
The top 5 journals account for 50% of the predicted probability mass.
Similar papers in this journal
- Alpha blocking and 1/fβ spectral scaling in resting EEG can be accounted for by a sum of damped alpha band oscillatory processes 94%
- Identification of Recurrent Dynamics in Distributed Neural Populations 94%
- Inferring a simple mechanism for alpha-blocking by fitting a neural population model to EEG spectra 94%
Similar papers in this journal
- A geometric approach to human stress based on stress-related surrogate measures 93%
- Computational modelling of the long-term effects of brain stimulation on the local and global structural connectivity of epileptic patients 92%
- Probabilistic, entropy-maximizing control of large-scale neural synchronization 92%
Similar papers in this journal
- Identifying task-relevant spectral signatures of perceptual categorization in the human cortex 93%
- Dynamic network properties of the interictal brain determine whether seizures appear focal or generalised 93%
- Temporal and spatiotemporal perturbations in paced finger tapping point to a common mechanism for the processing of time errors 92%
Similar papers in this journal
Similar papers in this journal
"Similar papers" are the closest papers from that journal in the model's embedding space. They show what the match is built on, but the ranking comes mostly from a classifier over the whole training set, not from these examples alone.