Early Ontogenetic Development of Tessellated Calcified Cartilage in Chondrichthyans

Tessellated calcified cartilage (TCC) is a hallmark of the chondrichthyan skeleton, yet its development early in ontogeny across the four major groups (batoids, galeomorphs, squalomorphs, and holocephalans) remains poorly understood. Specialised traits of TCC, such as multi-layered TCC and internal mineralised trabeculae, typically develop in response to feeding mechanics. In this study, we evaluated TCC morphology in the jaws of 12 representative taxa to observe its structure at an early ontogenetic stage to determine whether these specialised features had yet developed. Batoids consistently exhibited well-developed, homogeneous, polygonal tesserae early in ontogeny regardless of jaw morphology or feeding habit. In contrast, galeomorphs displayed high morphological heterogeneity. Notably, we document the first report of an extensive internal trabecular network in a non-batoid elasmobranch, observed in Ginglymostoma cirratum, which may serve to resist the mechanical pressures of specialised suction feeding. Furthermore, we identified voussoir tesserae in galeomorphs for the first time, extending their documented presence across all elasmobranch groups, where they display an inverted aspect ratio (wider than tall) compared to mature forms. The durophagous Mustelus mustelus exhibited surprisingly poor TCC development despite being a durophagous feeder, pointing to a pronounced ontogenetic lag. In Squatina oculata, TCC was characterised by large and thick tesserae and extensive fused tesseral regions which may relate to its explosive ambush predation mode, whereas the holocephalan Chimaera exhibited a poorly mineralized, mesh-like structure without resolvable discrete tesserae or trabeculae-matching findings from previous studies. Across all specimens, multi-layered TCC was absent, confirming that multi-layering develops later in ontogeny. These results demonstrate that generalised models of TCC development based on one group or a few taxa fail to capture the broader diversity of TCC morphology. It also opens up many exciting avenues for further study, and forms the basis for comparisons with fossil chondrichthyans, to investigate the evolution of TCC.