Criterion-selective neurons in the human medial frontal cortex track decision thresholds during memory-based decision making

The decision criterion is foundational to theories of decision-making, yet little is known about its neural underpinnings. In memory-based decision making, the criterion sets the minimal memory strength for something to be familiar, but whether or how it is distinctly represented from memory strength is unknown. We recorded single neurons in the medial frontal cortex (MFC) and medial temporal lobe (MTL), both implicated in memory-based decisions, while participants made decisions under different decision criteria. We identified criterion-selective (CS) neurons in the MFC that tracked the criterion regardless of memory strength, and memory-selective (MS) neurons in both regions that tracked memory strength regardless of the criterion. CS neurons signaled the criterion before MS neurons signaled memory strength, and a race model incorporating both neuron types outperformed one using MS neurons alone. These findings reveal two independent cellular substrates, one for the decision criterion and one for memory strength, whose joint activity underlies memory-based decisions.