Gene loss propensity for metallocarboxypeptidase E in insects is shaped by structural versatility and broader expression of metallocarboxypeptidase D but not functional importance

Gene loss is a widespread phenomenon that shapes genome evolution, yet the factors determining why certain genes are repeatedly lost while other functionally related genes are retained remain poorly understood. We addressed this question using the peptide-processing metallocarboxypeptidases carboxypeptidase E (CPE) and carboxypeptidase D (CPD), conserved paralogues that are essential for neuropeptide maturation but strikingly differ in their evolutionary fate: the cpe gene has been independently lost in two major insect lineages, whereas cpd/svr has been universally retained. Combining gene phylogenetic analyses and functional genetics in the beetle Tribolium castaneum, and cross-species rescue experiments in the fly Drosophila melanogaster, we show that CPE and CPD retained partially interchangeable enzymatic functions despite considerable differences in structure, organismal importance and expression. Contrary to expectations, cpe proved more critical than cpd/svr for survival and developmental robustness in Tribolium, while simultaneous RNAi-mediated downregulation of both genes caused complete larval lethality, demonstrating only partial functional redundancy. Moreover, beetle CPE partially rescued the lethal loss of Drosophila CPD, establishing conserved molecular interchangeability across [~]300 million years of insect evolution. Gene phylogenetic analyses further indicate that bilaterian CPE originated through duplication of the second catalytic domain of an ancestral CPD. Together, our results demonstrate that repeated loss of insect cpe cannot be explained by reduced functional importance. Instead, we propose that the structural versatility, broader tissue distribution and multifunctionality of CPD, including its multidomain architecture and splice isoforms, enabled compensation for CPE after gene loss, thereby shaping long-term patterns of gene retention and loss during insect evolution.