Aquatic bacterial metabolic rates from RNA quantitative stable isotope probing (RNA-qSIP) depend on experimental design

Quantitative stable isotope probing (qSIP) allows researchers to calculate taxon-specific carbon incorporation from sequencing of natural microbial communities, which can be used as a proxy for metabolic activity rates and subsequently as an input for biogeochemical modeling. While qSIP is widely utilized in soils to investigate the identity and metabolic activity of largely unculturable microbes, the application of qSIP in marine and aquatic ecosystems is more recent. Here, we investigated how bioreactor type (batch vs. chemostat) and carbon substrate complexity (single vs. multiple substrates) affect the incorporation of {superscript 1}3C-labeled glucose into rRNA after 24 hours using excess atomic fraction (EAF) as a proxy for metabolic activity rate. We found that the growth dynamics and community composition of the {superscript 1}3C-incorporating bacteria differed significantly for each treatment. EAF was positively correlated with both 16S gene copy number and a genomic index of copiotrophy in both batch treatments, but not in the chemostat, suggesting that chemostats dampen the competitive advantage of fast-growing copiotrophic taxa. Our results demonstrate that both substrate complexity and experimental regime influence qSIP-derived metabolic activity estimates and provide guidance for future applications of qSIP in aquatic environments.