A winding road to coexistence: Interdependence of niche and fitness differences in E. coli with targeted resource uptake gene deletions

Resource competition theory typically assumes static traits and continuous supply of resources. Yet microbial communities often experience feast-famine cycles and rapid trait change. To investigate coexistence under these nonequilibrium conditions, we integrate modern coexistence theory (MCT) with a genome-scale metabolic model that explicitly links resource use (traits) to metabolic fluxes and growth. MCT partitions competitive interactions into niche and fitness differences, to predict when trait-driven departures from neutrality result in coexistence or exclusion. Using dynamic flux balance analysis, we define a function that maps trait-resource matching to niche and fitness differences between species in a two-species two-resource system. This mapping shows that niche and fitness differences are not independently tunable under resource competition: changes in transporter-mediated resource uptake and changes in resource concentration ratios generate constrained trajectories through coexistence space. Specifically, we show that the minimum niche difference required for coexistence increases linearly with the absolute difference in maximal growth rates on limiting resources, showing how limiting similarity between species can emerge from intracellular metabolic constraints. Furthermore, we find that in batch culture simulations, initial conditions (inoculum size, total resource concentration) determine the timescale of the transient growth phase, with niche differences saturating and fitness differences increasing as the timescale grows, thereby governing competition outcomes. Finally, we test these predictions experimentally using E. coli strains with targeted resource transporter knockouts under both equal and skewed resource concentrations. Our results confirm that transporter-mediated trait changes and resource concentration ratio modulation can be harnessed to engineer coexistence. Together, our work demonstrates that trait-resource matching imposes structured constraints on the joint evolution of niche and fitness differences, thereby shaping biodiversity maintenance in microbial communities under nonequilibrium conditions.