Back

Guiding the development of climate counterfactuals for health impact attribution studies

Charnley, G. E. C.; Kotz, M.; Kawiecki Peralta, A.; Grayson, K. M.

2026-06-18 epidemiology
10.64898/2026.06.16.26355779 medRxiv
Show abstract

Climate change detection and attribution (D&A) methods have become vital for quantifying the influence of anthropogenic forcing on the Earth's systems, including human health. Health impact attribution (HIA) studies seek to disentangle climate-driven health effects from natural variability yet are often constrained by the availability of accessible counterfactual climate scenarios. This tutorial paper presents a flexible, reproducible framework for developing counterfactual climates without reliance on computationally intensive global circulation models. We provide practical, R-based methodologies for constructing both trend-based (temperature and non-temperature) and event-based counterfactual, using a variety of techniques including model residual detrending, data-driven decomposition (e.g., Singular Spectrum Analysis and Empirical Mode Decomposition) and stochastic weather generators. The tutorial also explores the incorporation of greenhouse gas concentrations as forcing variables, rather than global mean temperature anomalies. By operationalising these methods through worked examples and an open code repository, this paper aims to build capacity within the HIA community, enhance methodological transparency, and foster interdisciplinary collaboration between climate and health researchers.

Matching journals

The top 9 journals account for 50% of the predicted probability mass.

1
GeoHealth
● 12 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
9.7%
Similar papers in this journal
2
Environmental Health Perspectives
● 17 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
6.8%
Similar papers in this journal
3
Scientific Reports
○ 3612 papers in training set
Top 12%
6.3%
Similar papers in this journal
4
Environmental Research
○ 49 papers in training set
Top 0.2%
5.5%
Similar papers in this journal
5
PLOS ONE
● 5266 papers in training set
Top 28%
5.2%
Similar papers in this journal
6
BMC Medical Research Methodology
○ 47 papers in training set
Top 0.2%
4.9%
7
Nature Communications
○ 5641 papers in training set
Top 30%
4.3%
8
Scientific Data
○ 209 papers in training set
Top 0.6%
4.1%
9
BMJ Global Health
● 113 papers in training set
Top 1%
3.3%
50% of probability mass above
10
Infectious Disease Modelling
○ 54 papers in training set
Top 0.5%
2.8%
11
PLOS Global Public Health
● 344 papers in training set
Top 4%
2.8%
12
PLOS Computational Biology
● 1863 papers in training set
Top 13%
2.1%
13
American Journal of Epidemiology
◐ 67 papers in training set
Top 0.5%
2.1%
14
BMJ Open
● 601 papers in training set
Top 9%
1.7%
15
Environmental Science & Technology
● 64 papers in training set
Top 0.6%
1.7%
16
Science of The Total Environment
○ 186 papers in training set
Top 2%
1.7%
17
Frontiers in Public Health
○ 148 papers in training set
Top 4%
1.5%
18
International Journal of Epidemiology
◐ 88 papers in training set
Top 0.9%
1.5%
19
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
● 2444 papers in training set
Top 30%
1.5%
20
Environmental Research Letters
○ 14 papers in training set
Top 0.2%
1.3%
21
Royal Society Open Science
● 214 papers in training set
Top 4%
1.1%
22
Patterns
○ 78 papers in training set
Top 2%
1.0%
23
eClinicalMedicine
○ 77 papers in training set
Top 2%
0.8%
24
Bioinformatics
◐ 1204 papers in training set
Top 9%
0.8%
25
Swiss Medical Weekly
● 15 papers in training set
Top 0.2%
0.8%
26
Data in Brief
○ 14 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
0.8%
27
BMC Public Health
○ 158 papers in training set
Top 5%
0.8%
28
American Journal of Infection Control
○ 12 papers in training set
Top 0.2%
0.8%
29
IJID Regions
○ 11 papers in training set
Top 0.3%
0.8%
30
eLife
● 5828 papers in training set
Top 70%
0.6%

"Similar papers" are the closest papers from that journal in the model's embedding space. They show what the match is built on, but the ranking comes mostly from a classifier over the whole training set, not from these examples alone.