Comparative Thermal Effects of Single Shot Pulsed Field Ablation Systems using a Thermochromic Hydrogel

Background Pulse-field ablation (PFA) is regarded as a non-thermal ablation modality, but there is an increasing range of complications that could be due to thermal effects. Methods The hydrogel undergoes permanent colour change when a target temperature is reached allowing direct visualisation of the surface thermal footprint and depth. Comparative lesion sets using a variable loop circular catheter (VP), circular over-the-wire catheter (PS) and pentaspline catheter (FP) were performed. Protocols included single and stacked applications with variation of force, irrigation, and voltage. The hydrogel lesions were analysed en-face and by section using digital image analysis. Results All 3 PFA catheters tested had significant thermal footprints. The VP catheter had the largest mean surface footprint (156.1mm2) and thermal depth (1.31mm) compared to the other two catheters (PS 55.4mm2 & 1.1mm, FP 29.8mm2 & 1.05mm, p<0.005). Increasing irrigation showed a trend to reduce thermal footprint but did not achieve statistical significance. Increasing voltage increased thermal footprint, but increasing force had negligible effect. Stacked lesions incrementally increased thermal lesion footprint and depth in all catheters. Thermal depths of up to 2.4mm were observed. Areas of darkening and degradation of the hydrogel were observed with the VP and FP catheters, consisting of up to 47% of lesion area. No darkening was observed with the PS catheter. Conclusions There are significant thermal footprints in all the systems tested. Temperatures exceeding 60oC have been demonstrated, comparable to radiofrequency ablation, and this may explain the mechanism of injury in some reports of collateral damage during PFA.