Revisiting Plasmodium vivax molecular correction

Background: Reliable inference of Plasmodium vivax recurrence states - relapse, recrudescence and reinfection (the ``3Rs'') - improves estimates of antimalarial efficacy. The R package Pv3Rs features a Bayesian model designed for P. vivax molecular correction, i.e., using parasite genetic data to infer recurrence states. The model is an extension of a prototype built to analyse microsatellite data from the Vivax History (VHX) and Best Primaquine Dose (BPD) trials. Methods: We re-analysed data from 212 VHX and BPD trial participants (493 recurrences) using Pv3Rs, comparing results with those from the prototype and with genetic relatedness estimated using Dcifer, a tool for estimating relatedness based on identity-by-descent. Posterior recurrence state probabilities were computed using both uniform and time-to-event priors: artificial but equal prior probabilities facilitate posterior interpretation, while time-to-event priors leverage all available information and enable re-computation of failure rates. Relatedness estimates were used to identify and correct instances of model misspecification. Results: The Pv3Rs model generated posterior probabilities for all recurrences and was able to jointly model data on all episodes per participant for 89% of participants, compared with 73% using the prototype. Recurrence state probabilities were broadly consistent across methods, though the Pv3Rs model elevated reinfection probabilities slightly. Relatedness estimates exposed various outliers consistent with half-sibling parasites and/or genotyping errors. Outlier correction impacted some per-participant failure probabilities, but reinfection-adjusted radical-cure failure rates of high-dose primaquine remained near 3%, in line with previous findings. Conclusion: Re-analysis of VHX and BPD P. vivax genetic data restates earlier reinfection-adjusted efficacy estimates. It demonstrates the increased computational capability and misspecification sensitivity of Pv3Rs, highlighting a need for careful analyses. Using relatedness-based diagnostics alongside model-based inference, we were able to harness the advantages of model-based inference and provide a framework for future P. vivax molecular correction.