Opposing BOLD signals and oxygen metabolism largely arise from statistical uncertainty in metabolic estimates
Goltermann, O.; Huth, A. R.; Büchel, C.
Show abstract
Recent work by Epp et al. (2025) reported widespread voxel-wise sign discordance between task-evoked blood-oxygenation-level-dependent (BOLD) responses and estimated changes in cerebral metabolic rate of oxygen ({Delta}CMRO2), raising important questions about the interpretability of BOLD functional magnetic resonance imaging. Reanalysing the dataset, we found that {Delta}CMRO2 estimates showed substantial voxel-wise variability across participants, consistent with the noise sensitivity of model-based metabolic estimates. When this variability was taken into account, 77.2% of voxels could not be robustly classified, as {Delta}CMRO2 effects lacked sufficient statistical support to determine concordance or discordance. Where classification was possible, positive BOLD responses were predominantly concordant with metabolism, whereas discordance was considerably higher for negative BOLD responses. These findings suggest that the observed BOLD-metabolism discordance reported previously largely reflects statistical uncertainty in CMRO2 estimates rather than widespread physiological sign reversal.
Matching journals
The top 4 journals account for 50% of the predicted probability mass.
Similar papers in this journal
- The temporal specificity of BOLD fMRI is systematically related to anatomical and vascular features of the human brain 97%
- Evaluating the dependence of ADC-fMRI on haemodynamics inbreath-hold and resting-state conditions 97%
- On the analysis of functional PET (fPET)-FDG: baseline mischaracterization can introduce artifactual metabolic (de)activations 97%
Similar papers in this journal
- Comparing end-tidal CO2, respiration volume per time (RVT), and average gray matter signal for mapping cerebrovascular reactivity amplitude and delay with breath-hold task BOLD fMRI 97%
- A cortical hierarchy of localized and distributed processes revealed via dissociation of task activations, connectivity changes, and intrinsic timescales 96%
- Predicting Individual Traits from Unperformed Tasks 96%
Similar papers in this journal
- Voxel-wise Intermodal Coupling Analysis of Two or More Modalities using Local Covariance Decomposition 96%
- Prediction of individual melodic contour processing in sensory association cortices from resting state functional connectivity 96%
- Isolating the Sources of Pipeline-Variability in Group-Level Task-fMRI results 96%
Similar papers in this journal
Similar papers in this journal
"Similar papers" are the closest papers from that journal in the model's embedding space. They show what the match is built on, but the ranking comes mostly from a classifier over the whole training set, not from these examples alone.