Quantitative Assessment of Dual and Triple Energy Window Scatter Correction in Myocardial Perfusion SPECT with a 4D Phantom

Conflicting evidence on scatter correction (SC) methods plagues quantitative myocardial perfusion SPECT (MPI), hindering standardized clinical protocols. This simulation study, utilizing the SIMIND Monte Carlo program and a highly realistic 4D XCAT phantom, systematically evaluates Dual Energy Window (DEW, with k=0.5) and Triple Energy Window (TEW) SC techniques. We uniquely investigate their performance across various photopeak window widths (2, 4, and 6 keV) and novel overlapped/non overlapped configurations specifically for Tc 99m MPI parameters largely unexplored in realistic cardiac models. Images were reconstructed with OSEM under uncorrected (UC), SC, and combined attenuation and scatter corrected (ACSC) conditions. Quantitative analysis focused on signal to noise ratio (SNR), contrast to noise ratio (CNR), defect contrast, and relative noise to background (RNB). Our findings consistently show ACSC's superior performance in CNR, SNR, and defect contrast, confirming its critical role. Interestingly, SC alone reduced noise but compromised defect contrast relative to UC, highlighting a potential trade-off without attenuation correction. Crucially, this study reveals minimal influence of photopeak window width and overlap configuration on image quality, and no significant difference between DEW and TEW across most metrics. These results provide essential evidence for optimizing quantitative MPI protocols, suggesting that for Tc 99m, the choice between DEW and TEW, and specific window settings, may be less critical than ensuring robust attenuation correction.