A look inside the net: freshwater turtles assort with conspecifics in feeding aggregations

Non-avian reptiles have been assumed to be non-social for many years, yet recent studies show diverse social behaviours in squamates, crocodilians, and turtles. Here, we investigate social structure within feeding aggregations of three freshwater turtle species caught in baited traps in a coastal marsh over 12 years. In 488 instances in which traps contained turtles, 45% contained multiple individuals, and these aggregations were strongly positively assorted by species. midland painted turtles (Chrysemys picta) and Blandings turtles (Emydoidea blandingii) were captured with conspecifics more often than expected in a non-social null model. Snapping turtles (Chelydra serpentina), the largest species in this study, were caught with conspecifics at rates consistent with the non-social null model, and were avoided by heterospecifics. This suggests that species differences play a role in how feeding aggregations are structured, with painted and Blandings turtles driving positive species assortment while avoiding snapping turtles around food sources. We did not detect significant intraspecific sex assortment in any of the three species, nor did turtle body size strongly affect the probability of aggregating with conspecifics at the perceived food source in the traps. Our study illustrates how long-term monitoring data can be used to investigate social structure in wild populations, an approach that may be valuable for species of conservation concern. Significance StatementReptile sociality has been historically overlooked, but recent work has revealed intriguing social behaviours in non-avian reptiles. We investigated associations among three species of freshwater turtle, captured in baited traps over 12 years of trapping. Turtles in these feeding aggregations grouped with their own species more often than expected by chance. This result was driven by the two smaller-bodied species (midland painted turtle and Blandings turtle), which were more likely to be caught with conspecifics than with other species. In contrast, the largest species (snapping turtle) showed no evidence of attraction to other snapping turtles, and midland painted turtles and Blandings turtles showed avoidance of the larger snapping turtles. Our analyses illustrate how long-term monitoring data can be used to uncover previously unrecognized social behaviour in turtles and other species in which behaviour is difficult to observe directly.