Long-term impact of Training the Trainers program on Primary Eye Care networks in Malawi using the Arclight Project package
Windle, T.; Maliko, F.; Burgiss-Kasthala, S.; Blaikie, A.
Show abstract
Background The World Health Organisation (WHO) advocates integrating primary eye care (PEC) within community health systems, supported by task-shifting and frugal technologies. While low-cost tools such as the Arclight device and Wilson anterior segment loupe have demonstrated training and diagnostic value, their long-term impact on community health worker (CHW) roles and professional networks remain poorly understood. Methods We conducted a qualitative follow-up study 3 years after implementation of an Arclight Project enabled cascade training of the trainers (ToT) PEC programme in central Malawi. Ophthalmic Clinical Officers (OCOs) trained using the Arclight training and diagnostic package subsequently cascaded PEC training to Health Surveillance Assistants (HSAs). Semi-structured interviews were undertaken 3 years later with OCOs and HSAs to explore device use, evolving professional roles, training diffusion, and communication patterns. Data were analysed thematically, informed by concepts from social network analysis to examine changes in advice-seeking, mentorship and peer collaboration. Results Frugal eye-care technologies functioned not only as diagnostic tools but as mechanisms of professional repositioning. HSAs equipped with low-cost diagnostic devices became recognised as community eye focal persons, receiving referrals from colleagues and community members. OCOs who delivered training emerged as central hubs for clinical advice and ongoing training, creating strong vertical networks between district and community levels. However, horizontal peer-to-peer networks among HSAs remained weak and largely informal. Communication relied heavily on ad-hoc phone calls and WhatsApp messaging, with limited structured communities of practice. Despite sustained use of devices and retention of key skills, network activity often declined over time without active reinforcement. Conclusions Frugal eye-care technologies act as social as well as clinical interventions, reshaping CHW networks and professional hierarchies. Designing PEC programmes with explicit attention to strengthening and sustaining professional networks, rather than focusing solely on skills transfer, may further enhance alignment with WHO Integrated People-Centred Eye Care and improve long-term programme sustainability and impact.
Matching journals
The top 3 journals account for 50% of the predicted probability mass.