The first step is not always the hardest: A change-point analysis of predictive learning

The progress of learning is usually quantified by averaging responses across participants and/or multiple trials within a block. However, such approaches obscure the trial-by-trial progress of learning, which has been shown recently to express a rich variety of dynamics. An alternative approach which does not suffer from this problem is the detection and analysis of points of behavioral change, i.e., change-point analysis. Using change-point analysis, we reanalyzed data from human participants in different predictive learning tasks in which learned contingencies underwent reversal. We find that responses of individual participants were more accurately characterized by behavioral change points than the average learning curve. Importantly, change points significantly shifted to later trials during reversal learning indicating that reversal learning is more difficult than the initial learning. In a computational model based on deep reinforcement learning, we show that the change point shift required the replay of previous experiences, which in turn depends on the hippocampus. This finding is consistent with studies showing that lesions of the hippocampus yield faster reversal learning. In summary, we reaffirm the importance of the analysis of single participant responses, show that phenomenological learning rates are slower during reversal learning, and provide a theoretical account for this difference.