The not-so-great speciator: Systematics and species limits in a rapid radiation, the Asiatic white-eye complex (Zosterops spp.)

Abstract/SummaryHere we untangle the systematics of the Asiatic white-eye complex (Zosterops spp.) to better understand the early stages of a recent island radiation. We adopt an integrative approach involving allelic data, genome-scale single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), and museum-based morphometrics coupled with a comprehensive sampling to provide the most holistic understanding of the group to date. The island lineages of Asiatic white-eyes across Indonesia, the Philippines, East Asia, the adjacent oceanic islands of the Western Pacific underwent a deep split separating Zosterops everetti and Z. nigrorum in the Phillippines from a very rapid radiation including Z. japonicus, Z. meyeni, and Z. montanus in the Philippines, Japan, and Indonesia. Z. nigrorum catarmanensis on Camiguin South in the Philippines was found to be nested within Z. montanus and a species limit between Z. nigrorum populations on Panay and Luzon was strongly supported. Phylogenetic splits and population structure were detected within the clade containing Z. japonicus, Z. meyeni, and Z. montanus. A well-supported split separates a northern group including Northern Philippines Z. montanus subspecies, Z. meyeni, and Z. japonicus from the southerly Z. montanus taxa. This creates a paraphyletic Z. montanus. However, based on speciation rates within the broader Asiatic white-eye clade this break likely does not yet represent evolutionarily independent species lineages. Morphological evolution is taking place within the Asiatic white-eyes especially within the robust, large-billed subspecies of Z. japonicus on the oceanic islands of Japan and in the newly identified yellow-morph of Z. montanus on Camiguin South.