Pleistocene climatic oscillations impact the diversification of deer mice (Peromyscus maniculatus) and the independent evolution of ecotypes

A central question in evolutionary biology is whether local adaptation is predictable when a species repeatedly encounters similar environments. The deer mouse, Peromyscus maniculatus, has a range of over 13 million km2 in North America and may be found in nearly every terrestrial habitat. Because of their abundance and wide habitat preference, deer mice and closely related Peromyscus, which we refer to as the P. maniculatus species complex, are at the forefront of studies of biogeography and local adaptation. Here, we undertake a comprehensive survey of genome-wide and phenotypic diversity to characterize the recent evolutionary history of this group. We sequenced whole genomes from 232 individuals across their range, representing the most thorough genetic sampling of the P. maniculatus species complex to date. We identify six geographically delineated clades, several of which encompass both classically recognized P. maniculatus subspecies as well as other recognized species. Ecological niche modelling suggests that this geographic structure resulted from rapid post-LGM range expansion and adaptation to emerging habitats. Our morphological measurements of 979 specimens and field data compiled from over 28,000 museum records show that deer mice in forests across the range consistently have longer tails, larger feet, bigger ears, and elongated whiskers. These traits constitute an arboreal ecotype that has evolved at least three times independently, and was likely lost in other parts of the range as populations moved out of forested habitat. Altogether, these results suggest that post-LGM increases in forested habitat drove the parallel evolution of arboreal ecotypes across the deer mouse range.