Back

Pitfalls in estimating the global carbon removal via forest expansion - a comment on Bastin et al. (2019)

Krause, A.; Arneth, A.; Bayer, A.; Buras, A.; Knoke, T.; Zang, C.; Rammig, A.

2019-10-05 ecology
10.1101/788026 bioRxiv
Show abstract

We believe the carbon removal potential of 205 Gt C reported by Bastin et al. (2019) to be overestimated. The authors did not consider the carbon already stored on the land with identified tree restoration potential. For instance, grasslands and degraded forests have similar soil carbon stocks as old-growth forests. Accounting for these inconsistencies in the calculation, we estimate a carbon removal potential of 81 Gt C, i.e. only 39% of the Bastin et al. estimate. In addition, some of the assumptions about potential restoration area seem questionable and an essential question remains unanswered: why do areas identified as suitable for tree growth currently lack tree cover?

Matching journals

The top 4 journals account for 50% of the predicted probability mass.

1
Environmental Research Letters
○ 14 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
22.6%
2
Global Change Biology
○ 78 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
18.7%
3
Science of The Total Environment
○ 186 papers in training set
Top 0.4%
8.0%
4
Global Ecology and Biogeography
○ 47 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
6.8%
50% of probability mass above
5
Ecological Indicators
○ 21 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
3.3%
6
Conservation Biology
○ 17 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
3.3%
7
eLife
● 5828 papers in training set
Top 43%
2.1%
8
PeerJ
◐ 308 papers in training set
Top 4%
2.1%
9
Biological Conservation
○ 46 papers in training set
Top 0.5%
1.9%
10
Journal of Geophysical Research: Biogeosciences
● 11 papers in training set
Top 0.1%
1.8%
11
Nature Communications
○ 5641 papers in training set
Top 45%
1.7%
12
Journal of Environmental Management
○ 13 papers in training set
Top 0.3%
1.5%
13
Conservation Letters
○ 14 papers in training set
Top 0.2%
1.5%
14
Ecology and Evolution
○ 267 papers in training set
Top 4%
1.1%
15
Peer Community Journal
● 281 papers in training set
Top 4%
1.1%
16
PLOS ONE
● 5266 papers in training set
Top 54%
1.1%
17
Biodiversity and Conservation
○ 12 papers in training set
Top 0.3%
1.1%
18
Conservation Science and Practice
○ 15 papers in training set
Top 0.4%
1.1%
19
Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution
○ 69 papers in training set
Top 3%
0.9%
20
Journal of Ecology
○ 49 papers in training set
Top 0.7%
0.9%
21
Ecological Informatics
○ 33 papers in training set
Top 0.8%
0.6%
22
FACETS
● 14 papers in training set
Top 0.6%
0.6%
23
Ecography
○ 54 papers in training set
Top 1%
0.6%
24
Ecological Applications
○ 34 papers in training set
Top 1.0%
0.6%
25
Journal of Applied Ecology
○ 39 papers in training set
Top 1%
0.6%
26
Sustainability
○ 10 papers in training set
Top 0.6%
0.6%
27
Communications Earth & Environment
○ 14 papers in training set
Top 0.4%
0.6%