Evaluating kin and group selection theory as tools for analyzing microbial data
smith, j.; Inglis, R. F.
Show abstract
For understanding the evolution of social behavior in microbes, mathematical theory can aid empirical research but is often only used as a qualitative heuristic. How to properly formulate social evolution theory has also been contentious. Here we evaluate kin and multilevel selection theory as tools for analyzing microbial data. We reanalyze published datasets that share a common experimental design and evaluate these theories in terms of data visualization, statistical performance, biological interpretation, and quantitative comparison across systems. We find that the canonical formulations of both kin and multilevel selection are almost always poor analytical tools because they use statistical regressions that are poorly specified for the strong selection and nonadditive fitness effects common in microbial systems. Analyzing both individual and group fitness outcomes helps clarify the biology of selection. We also identify analytical practices in empirical research that suggest how theory might better handle the challenges of microbial data. A quantitative, data-driven approach thus shows how kin and multilevel selection theory both have substantial room for improvement as tools for understanding social evolution in all branches of life.
Matching journals
The top 6 journals account for 50% of the predicted probability mass.
Similar papers in this journal
- Mutation bias can shape adaptation in large asexual populations experiencing clonal interference 95%
- Disruption of cross-feeding interactions by invading taxa can cause invasional meltdown in microbial communities 94%
- Effects of local versus global competition on reproductive skew and sex differences in social dominance behaviour 94%
Similar papers in this journal
- Quantitative Genetics of Microbiome Mediated Traits 94%
- Molecular signatures of resource competition: clonal interference favors ecological diversification and can lead to incipient speciation 93%
- The mutation effect reaction norm (Mu-RN) highlights environmentally dependent mutation effects and genetic interactions 93%
Similar papers in this journal
- Epistasis decreases with increasing antibiotic pressure but not temperature 95%
- Cultural specialization as a double-edged sword: division into specialized guilds might promote cultural complexity at the cost of higher susceptibility to cultural loss 94%
- Conjugative plasmid transfer is limited by prophages but can be overcome by high conjugation rates 93%
Similar papers in this journal
"Similar papers" are the closest papers from that journal in the model's embedding space. They show what the match is built on, but the ranking comes mostly from a classifier over the whole training set, not from these examples alone.