A multiscale physicochemical characterization of melanin-based feather coloration in the rapid Capuchino Seedeater radiation

Melanin-based plumage coloration in birds is shaped by pigment composition as well as melanosome morphology and distribution, however, the ways in which these factors together modulate observable color remain poorly understood. We investigate this relationship in the Capuchino Seedeaters (genus Sporophila), whose recent, rapid radiation driven by sexual selection resulted in 12 species with diverse coloration patterns. Using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and micro-computed tomography ({micro}CT), combined with a novel application of Fontana-Masson stain to image melanosomes at high resolution, we characterize melanosome distribution and morphology in several variably colored plumage patches across Capuchino species. Melanosome morphologies followed patch-specific patterns that did not directly correlate with coloration: crown feather melanosomes were larger, more elongated, and had greater percent eumelanin content than those in belly, throat, or dorsum/rump patches. We also observed that dorsal patches had more total melanin than ventral ones, with pigment and coloration patterns suggesting possible signaling and photoprotective roles. More generally, we show how the patch-specific coloration of male Capuchinos is accompanied by differences in melanosome morphology and melanin composition and abundance. Our work highlights the challenges that remain in understanding how the nanoscale mechanisms of melanin-based pigmentation translate into macroscale plumage coloration.