The host range paradox of Meloidogyne incognita: a physiological and transcriptomic analysis of nine susceptible interactions across six plant orders

The plant-parasitic nematode Meloidogyne incognita is the pathogen with the broadest host range among all known biotrophic interactions. This species is also the single most damaging of a group of agriculturally important plant-parasites, which together are estimated to contribute to losses in excess of $170 billion/year to world agriculture. Understanding how M. incognita is able to infect representatives from most orders of flowering plants, covering more than 3000 species, addresses a fundamentally important question of how pathogens adapt to their host-environment, and may inform control of a pathogen which threatens global food security. Here, we analyse the plant-nematode infection phenotype, and cross-kingdom transcriptome, of nine interactions across six orders of flowering plants at 25 days post infection. At this stage, majority of nematodes found within roots were immature and mature females (49.2% - 91.8%). Our data show that the phylogenetic distribution of hosts does not explain the phenotypic distribution of parasitism. Interestingly, though, M. incognita do have distinct transcriptional responses to different groups of hosts, but in a pattern which is independent of host phylogenetic. Three distinct nematode "transcriptional programmes" - Group 1, 2, and 3 - are evident, and we find that effectors are neither uniformly deployed across hosts, nor across groups of hosts. Importantly, we show that this differential deployment of effectors can have profound consequences for host specificity. Finally, we show that there is essentially no widespread core gall transcriptome at 25 days post infection, prompting the proposal of a model best described as "all roads lead to Rome".