Adeno-associated virus (AAV)-TBX18 does not generate biological pacemaker activity, unlike AAV-Hcn2

Gene therapy-based biological pacemakers have been proposed as an alternative to their hardware-based counterparts. In this context, short-term ectopic expression of the T-box transcription factor 18 (TBX18) in the ventricle reportedly generated potent short-term pacemaker function in various animal models. Here, we investigated the effect of adeno-associated virus (AAV)-mediated long-term expression of TBX18, and compared the outcome to that of the pacemaker ion channel Hcn2. Our findings revealed that CMV-driven ectopic TBX18 expression in mouse hearts led to severe cardiac fibrosis. At lower, non-fibrogenic levels, TBX18 maintained its transcriptional function but failed to induce pacemaker phenotypes. TBX18-expressing cells showed suppressed expression of key working myocardial genes, but the pacemaker gene program was not induced. Electrophysiological studies showed abnormal automaticity in TBX18-expressing cells, combined with prolonged repolarization and various current changes. However, no hyperpolarization-activated funny current was detected. In a complete AV-block rat model, AAV-mediated Hcn2 expression induced robust ectopic pacemaker activity in the presence of isoproterenol, whereas TBX18 expression neither generated such activities, nor augmented Hcn2-mediated pacing. In conclusion, at functional non-fibrogenic levels, TBX18 is neither sufficient nor necessary to induce pacemaker activity. In contrast, Hcn2 generates reliable pacing, making it a more viable candidate for biological pacemaker development.