Wearable tracking of walking and non-walking as progression markers in early Parkinson's disease
Ho, K. C.; Li, S.; Serrano Amenos, C.; Kowahl, N.; Rainaldi, E.; Chen, C.; Bloem, B. R.; Sanders, L. H.; Shih, L. C.; Siderowf, A.; Marks, W. J.; Kapur, R.; Evers, L. J. W.; Shin, S.
Show abstract
IMPORTANCEWearable-based measures of walking (as proxy for physical activity) may quantify disease progression and modification thereof in early-stage Parkinsons disease (PD). OBJECTIVESEstablishing the validity of digital measures of walking and non-walking in PD. DESIGNRetrospective longitudinal analyses of data from cohorts within 3 larger studies, consisting of wearable sensor, demographic, and clinical data collected during 2017-2023, with 1-2 year follow up. SETTINGThree independent multicenter cohort studies. PARTICIPANTSPeople with PD, and age/sex matched non-PD cohort. EXPOSURESNone. MAIN OUTCOMES AND MEASURESDigital measures test-retest reliability, analyzed using intraclass correlation coefficients across consecutive monthly-aggregated data. Digital measures sensitivity: ability to detect within-participant changes, analyzed over 24 months using linear mixed-effect models, and analyzed as effect-size changes-from-baseline comparing 1- and 2-year longitudinal Cohens-d (mean and 95% CIs) vs conventional clinical endpoints. Analyses replicated in two independent PD cohorts (internal validation and external evaluation). Compared within-participant changes between PD and non-PD cohorts using linear mixed-effect model slopes. RESULTSWe analyzed 57 digital measures (51 individual, 6 composite) in a development cohort (N=171), selecting 32 (26 individual, 6 composite) for further study based on their sensitivity and test-retest reliability. During internal validation (N=101), 20 measures could detect statistically significant within-participant changes and 7 showed larger 2-year effect-size changes than conventional clinical measures; non-walking bout (NWB) duration (12.4% yearly change; 2-year Cohens-d 0.623 [95% CI: 0.461,0.811]) and 95th percentile of NWB duration (17.1% yearly change; 2-year Cohens-d, 0.623 [95% CI: 0.461,0.811]) performed best. Measures could detect significant and persisting changes from baseline at 10 months. During external evaluation (N=67), 15 measures could detect statistically significant within-participant changes and 12 showed larger 1-year effect-size changes than conventional clinical measures; 12 measures showed significantly greater change in people with PD than in matched non-PD individuals (N=171). CONCLUSION AND RELEVANCEInternal validation and external evaluation of 32 digital measures that quantified walking and non-walking behaviors in patients with early-stage PD showed that they could have greater sensitivity to detect longitudinal changes than conventional measures, and that these changes were disease-specific (e.g., separate from aging), making them candidates for disease-specific progression markers. Key PointsO_ST_ABSQuestionC_ST_ABSCan wearable sensor-based digital measures of physical activity and mobility serve as markers of disease progression in early-stage Parkinsons disease (PD)? FindingsIn two independent longitudinal cohorts of people with PD, digital measures detected statistically-significant changes in walking and non-walking behaviors after 1 and 2 years of follow-up; additionally, a comparison between people with and without PD (from a third cohort) showed that these changes were disease-specific. Compared with MDS-UPDRS-based conventional metrics, measures of non-walking behavior showed greater effect size (such as mean non-walking bout duration, with an annual increase of 12.4% and a 2-year Cohens-d of 0.623). MeaningWearable sensor-based digital measures can detect and quantify disease-specific changes in walking and non-walking behaviors over time in people with early-stage PD.
Matching journals
The top 5 journals account for 50% of the predicted probability mass.