The fitness landscape of the E.coli lac operator is highly rugged in two different environments

We know little about the fitness landscapes of bacterial operators, regulatory DNA elements that are crucial to regulate metabolic genes like those of the lac operon for lactose utilization. For example, we do not know whether adaptive evolution could easily create strong operators from weak ones or from non-regulatory DNA. To find out, we used CRISPR-Cas-assisted genome editing, bulk competition, and high-throughput sequencing to map the fitness landscape of more than 140,000 lac operator variants in two chemical environments that harbor lactose or glycerol as sole carbon sources. Both landscapes are highly rugged and contain thousands of fitness peaks, which allow only 2 percent of evolving populations to reach a high fitness peak. The landscapes share only 15 percent of fitness peaks. Our work illustrates that landscape ruggedness caused by epistasis can represent an important obstacle to adaptive evolution of regulatory sequences. It also shows that a simple environmental change can substantially affect fitness landscape topography.