Conspecific brood parasitism in the barn swallow (Hirundo rustica)

Conspecific brood parasitism (CBP) has been reported in many altricial avian species, yet its prevalence and underlying behavioural mechanisms remain poorly understood. We studied CBP in the barn swallow (Hirundo rustica), a species in which conspecific brood parasitism has been reported. We conducted parentage analysis on 1945 barn swallow broods involving 7816 offspring. Samples were collected over 12 breeding seasons at 5 colonies/populations. Contrary to expectations, we identified only six cases of CBP (0.3 % of broods). By identifying all individuals involved, i.e. the parasitic females, the female hosts and the males that fathered the parasitic eggs, we determined these cases of CBP resulted most likely from either a failed nest take-over (three times), the disappearance of a female partner or a disruption caused by researchers while only one case could be interpreted as a result of females mixed reproductive tactic. Based on a review of the literature on CBP in seven other Hirundinidae, we conclude that the only reliable evidence for CBP comes from cliff swallows (Petrochelidon pyrrhonata). Studies on other species either failed to identify the parasitic females or do not present sufficient evidence supporting the occurrence of CBP. Several studies relied on the appearance of two eggs in a nest within 24 hours to conclude that CBP occurred. However, based on the parentage analysis, we show that CBP only occurred in one out of 11 such cases in our barn swallow data. Our findings highlight that CBP is rare in our barn swallow populations, and have been likely overestimated in other studies. We emphasize the importance of frequent nest checks and rigorous genetic validation in CBP research. Overall, our results challenge existing assumptions about the prevalence of CBP and provide insights into the behavioural mechanisms that lead to CBP, with ecological and evolutionary implications.