Essential strategies for the detection of constitutive and ligand-dependent Gi-directed activity of 7TM receptors using bioluminescence resonance energy transfer

The constitutive (ligand-independent) signaling of G protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs) is being increasingly appreciated as an integral aspect of their function; however, it can be technically hard to detect for poorly characterized, e.g. orphan, receptors of the cAMP-inhibitory Gi-coupled (GiPCR) family. In this study, we delineate the optimal strategies for the detection of such activity across several GiPCRs in two cell lines. As our study examples, we chose two canonical GiPCRs - the constitutively active Smoothened and the ligand-activated CXCR4,-and one atypical GPCRs, the chemokine receptor ACKR3. We verified the applicability of three Bioluminescence Resonance Energy Transfer (BRET)-based assays - one measuring changes in intracellular cAMP, another in G{beta}{gamma}/GRK3ct association and third in Gi-G{beta}{gamma} dissociation, - for assessing both constitutive and ligand-modulated activity of these receptors. We also revealed the possible caveats and sources of false positives, and proposed optimization strategies. All three types of assays confirmed the ligand-dependent activity of CXCR4, the controversial G protein incompetence of ACKR3, the constitutive Gi-directed activity of SMO, and its modulation by PTCH1. We also demonstrated that PTCH1 promotes SMO localization to the cell surface, thus enhancing its responsiveness not only to agonists but also to antagonists, which is a novel mechanism of regulation of a Class F GiPCR Smoothened.