Deconstructing CTL-mediated autoimmunity through weak TCR-cross-reactivity towards highly abundant self-antigen

T-cell antigen receptors (TCRs) exhibit inherent cross-reactivity which broadens the spectrum of epitopes that are recognizable by a finite TCR-repertoire but also carries the risk of autoimmunity. However, TCRs support also a high level of antigen specificity as they allow T-cells to discriminate single antigenic peptide/MHC complexes (pMHCs) against millions of structurally related self-pMHCs, in some cases based on the absence or presence of a single methyl-group. How TCRs manage to convey such seemingly contrary properties and why some T-cells become over time autoreactive despite negative thymic selection, has remained elusive. Here, we devised a non-invasive molecular live cell imaging platform to investigate the biophysical parameters governing stimulatory TCR:pMHC interactions in settings of autoreactivity and anti-viral responses - two extremes in T-cell antigen recognition. We show that CMV-specific CD8+ RA14-T-cells respond effectively to even a single HLA-A2/CMV (A2/CMV) antigen, with synaptic TCR:pMHC lifetimes lasting seconds. In contrast, cross-reactivity of type 1 diabetes (T1D)-associated CD8+ 1E6 T-cells towards HLA-A2/preproinsulin (A2/PPI) self-epitopes involved ten-fold less stable synaptic TCR interactions resulting in severely attenuated ZAP70 recruitment and downstream signaling. Compared to A2/CMV-engaged RA14 T-cells, 1E6-T-cells required for activation 4000 or more A2/PPI and at least 100-times as many simultaneously pMHC-engaged TCRs. In support of antigen discrimination, CD8 co-engagement of MHC class I (MHCI) strengthened both settings of TCR:pMHC interactions equally but was essential only for sensitized virus detection but not autorecognition (1000-versus 5-fold enhancement). We conclude that the binding dynamics of TCRs and CD8 with pMHC shape the boundaries of central tolerance in the physiological context of the phenomenal yet also differential T-cell antigen detection capacity, TCR-cross-reactivity and self-antigen abundance. Gained insights are integral to a molecular and quantitative understanding of CD8+ T-cell mediated autoimmunity and protective immunity against infections and cancer. ONE SENTENCE SUMMARYWith the use of newly devised molecular live-cell imaging modalities we measured with unprecedented precision T-cell antigen recognition dynamics in human T-cells in settings of anti-viral immunity and autoimmunity-causing cross-reactivity. These two extremes within the spectrum of T-cell antigen detection differed substantially with regard to synaptic TCR: antigen-engagement, the level of sensitization through the CD8-coreceptor and the overall efficiency of ensuing downstream signaling. Our results demarcate limits of central tolerance and protective immunity and set quantitative boundaries on the occurrence of autoimmunity with direct implications for T-cell-based designs of immunotherapies.