1-Aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid oxidase determines the fate of ethylene biosynthesis in a tissue-specific way to fine-tune development and stress resilience

Ethylene is involved in several developmental processes and responses towards (a)biotic stress. In seed plants, ethylene is produced from its precursor 1-aminocyclopropane-1-carboxylic acid (ACC) by the enzyme ACC-oxidase (ACO). Despite its key role in ethylene synthesis, the ACO gene family has not yet been fully characterized. We investigated the five ACO members of Arabidopsis thaliana and revealed a tissue-and developmentally specific expression pattern. Furthermore, the five ACO enzymes each have a different capacity to produce ethylene. Combined, this allows for a precise spatial and temporal regulation of ethylene synthesis. At the sub-cellular level, we uncovered that ACOs reside in the cytosol, where ethylene is likely synthesized, but surprisingly also in the nucleus. Using reverse genetics of single and higher order aco mutants we revealed a high degree of gene redundancy and minimal phenotypes. A lack of ethylene synthesis by knocking out all five ACOs did not impair normal vegetative and generative development but did influence processes associated with high rates of ethylene production such as petal abscission. This suggests that ethylene is not a prime regulator of development, but more a moderator. We also showed that the inability to synthesize ethylene impairs some abiotic (nutrient deficiency and metal toxicity) and biotic (Botrytis cinerea) stress responses, similar as plants insensitive towards ethylene, corroborating the role of ethylene in mediating stress responses. In conclusion, the ACO gene family enables plants to fine-tune their ethylene synthesis rates, but a lack their off is not crucial for normal development and stress survival.