Comparison of gene expression in living and postmortem human brain
Collado-Torres, L.; Klei, L.; Liu, C.; Kleinman, J. E.; Hyde, T. M.; Geschwind, D. H.; Gandal, M. J.; Devlin, B.; Weinberger, D. R.
Show abstract
Molecular mechanisms of neuropsychiatric disorders are challenging to study in human brain. For decades, the preferred model has been to study postmortem human brain samples despite the limitations they entail. A recent study generated RNA sequencing data from biopsies of prefrontal cortex from living patients with Parkinsons Disease and compared gene expression to postmortem tissue samples, from which they found vast differences between the two. This led the authors to question the utility of postmortem human brain studies. Through re-analysis of the same data, we unexpectedly found that the living brain tissue samples were of much lower quality than the postmortem samples across multiple standard metrics. We also performed simulations that illustrate the effects of ignoring RNA degradation in differential gene expression analyses, showing the effects can be substantial and of similar magnitude to what the authors find. For these reasons, we believe the authors conclusions are unjustified. To the contrary, while opportunities to study gene expression in the living brain are welcome, evidence that this eclipses the value of postmortem analyses is not apparent.
Matching journals
The top 9 journals account for 50% of the predicted probability mass.
Similar papers in this journal
Similar papers in this journal
- Using multiple measurements of tissue to estimate subject- and cell-type-specific gene expression 95%
- Identification of cell-type-specific marker genes from co-expression patterns in tissue samples 94%
- DataRemix: a universal data transformation for optimal inference from gene expression datasets 93%
Similar papers in this journal
"Similar papers" are the closest papers from that journal in the model's embedding space. They show what the match is built on, but the ranking comes mostly from a classifier over the whole training set, not from these examples alone.