Clonal stochasticity in early NK cell response to mouse cytomegalovirus is generated by mature subsets of varying proliferative ability

Natural killer (NK) cells are classically defined as innate immune cells, but experiments show that mouse cytomegalovirus (MCMV) infection in C57BL/6 mice can cause NK cells to undergo antigen-specific proliferation and memory formation, similar to adaptive CD8+ T cells. One shared behavior between CD8+ T cells and NK cells is clonal expansion, where a single stimulated cell proliferates rapidly to form a diverse population of cells. For example, clones derived from single cells are most abundant during expansion when they are primarily CD27-for NK cells and CD62L-for T cells, phenotypes derived from precursor CD27+ and CD62L+ cells, respectively. Here we determined the mechanistic rules involving proliferation, cell death, and differentiation of endogenous and adoptively transferred NK cells in the expansion phase of the response to MCMV infection. We found that the interplay between cell proliferation and cell death of mature CD27-NK cells and a highly proliferative CD27-Ly6C-mature subtype and intrinsic stochastic fluctuations in these processes play key roles in regulating the heterogeneity and population of the NK cell subtypes. Furthermore, we estimate rates for maturation of endogenous NK cells in homeostasis and in MCMV infection and found that only NK cell growth rates, and not differentiation rates, are appreciably increased by MCMV. Taken together, these results quantify the differences between the kinetics of NK cell antigen-specific expansion from that of CD8+ T cells and unique mechanisms that give rise to the observed heterogeneity in NK cell clones generated from single NK cells in the expansion phase.