The evolution of competitive effectiveness and tolerance in populations of Drosophila melanogaster adapted to chronic larval crowding at varying combinations of egg number and food volume

The theory of density-dependent selection posits that genotypic fitness can vary depending on the population density. Several long-term selection experiments on outbred populations of Drosophila adapted to chronically high larval densities have shown that the most common evolutionary response of such rearing is an increase in larval competitive ability. Some authors have proposed that a better understanding of the evolution of competitive ability can be achieved by its partitioning into effectiveness and tolerance components. Effectiveness is the amount of competitive inhibition imposed by a competitor on another, whereas tolerance is the degree to which a competitor can withstand inhibition. In this study, we have explored the evolution of effectiveness and tolerance components of competitive ability using three sets of outbred populations of D. melanogaster adapted to chronic larval crowding at different respective combinations of egg number, food volume and container dimensions. Effectiveness and tolerance were found to be dependent on the particular selection regime, the starting food amount and the trait used as the outcome of competition. Eclosion, dry biomass and dry weight per fly distributions over time indicated that competitive ability can also express itself in a time-dependent manner. The results suggest that larval competition and the evolution of competitive ability in Drosophila are extremely nuanced.