Comparative analysis of myoglobin in Cetaceans and humans reveals novel regulatory elements and evolutionary flexibility

Cetacea and other diving mammals have undergone numerous adaptations to their aquatic environment, among them high levels of the oxygen-carrying intracellular hemoprotein myoglobin in skeletal muscles, especially those responsible for swimming. Hypotheses regarding the mechanisms leading to these high myoglobin levels often invoke exercise, hypoxia, and other physiological pathways that impact gene regulation, and increase myoglobin gene expression. Here we explore an alternative hypothesis: that Cetacean myoglobin genes have evolved high levels of transcription driven by the intrinsic developmental mechanisms that drive muscle cell differentiation. We have used luciferase assays in differentiated C2C12 cells to test this hypothesis. Contrary to our hypothesis, we find that the myoglobin gene from the minke whale, Balaenoptera acutorostrata, has a low level of expression, less than 10% that of humans. This low expression level is broadly shared among Cetaceans, and Artiodactylans. Previous work on regulation of the human gene has identified a core muscle-specific enhancer comprised of two regions, the "AT element" and a C-rich sequence 5 of the AT element termed the "CCAC-box". Comparative analysis of the minke whale gene supports the importance of the AT element, but the minke whale CCAC-box ortholog has little effect. Instead, critical positive input has been identified in a G-rich region 3 of the AT element. Also, a conserved E-box in exon 1 positively affects expression, despite having been assigned a repressive role in the human gene. Last, a novel region 5 of the core enhancer has been identified, which we hypothesize may function as a boundary element. These results illustrate regulatory flexibility during evolution. They also support the hypothesis that the induction of transcription by physiological signaling pathways, and evolved protein stability are important in leading to the high myoglobin protein levels found in Cetaceans.