Non-decision time: the Higg's boson of decision
Bompas, A.; Sumner, P.; Hedge, C.
Show abstract
Generative models of decision now permeate all subfields of psychology, cognitive and clinical neuroscience. To successfully represent decision mechanisms, it is necessary to also assume the presence of delays for sensory and motor information to travel through the brain; but like the Higgs boson in particle physics, directly observing this "non-decision time" from behaviour long appeared beyond reach. Here, we describe and apply a set of methods to empirically measure and characterise the properties of non-decision time in fast visually guided decisions (without requiring modelling assumptions). We gather 11 datasets from humans and monkeys from multiple labs and validate the method by showing that visual properties (brightness, colour, size) consistently affect empirically measured non-decision time, as predicted by neurophysiology. We then show that endogenous factors (pro-active slowing, attention) consistently do not affect non-decision time, in contrast to widespread reports based on model fits. Last, contrasting empirically observed non-decision time with estimates from the EZ, DDM and LBA models, we conclude that models cannot be generally trusted to provide valid estimates, either at a group level or for individual differences, and propose a hybrid approach that combines our empirical method with standard modelling.
Matching journals
The top 9 journals account for 50% of the predicted probability mass.
Similar papers in this journal
Similar papers in this journal
Similar papers in this journal
- Learning decouples accuracy and reaction time for rapid decisions in a transitive inference task 96%
- Dynamic interplay between reward and voluntary attention determines stimulus processing in visual cortex 95%
- Alpha-band frequency and temporal windows in perception: A review and living meta-analysis of 27 experiments (and counting) 95%
Similar papers in this journal
- Information processing in the Hand Laterality Judgement Task: Fundamental differences between dorsal and palmar views revealed by a Forced Response paradigm 95%
- Theory of Visual Attention (TVA) in Action: Assessing Premotor Attention in Simultaneous Eye-Hand Movements 95%
- Model-free decision making resists improved instructions and is enhanced by stimulus-response associations 94%
Similar papers in this journal
- Variance (un)explained: Experimental conditions and temporal dependencies explain similarly small proportions of reaction time variability in linear models of perceptual and cognitive tasks 97%
- Scanning along a compressed timeline of the future 95%
- Two faces of perceptual awareness during the attentional blink: Gradual and discrete 95%
"Similar papers" are the closest papers from that journal in the model's embedding space. They show what the match is built on, but the ranking comes mostly from a classifier over the whole training set, not from these examples alone.