Differential Regulation of mTor signaling defines subtypes of cblX syndrome

Mutations in the HCFC1 transcriptional co-factor protein are the cause of cblX syndrome and X-linked intellectual disability (XLID). cblX is the more severe disorder associated with intractable epilepsy, abnormal cobalamin metabolism, facial dysmorphia, cortical gyral malformations, and intellectual disability. In vitro, Hcfc1 regulates neural precursor (NPCs) proliferation and number, which has been validated in zebrafish. However, conditional deletion of Hcfc1 in Nkx2.1+ NPCs increased cell death, reduced Gfap expression, and reduced numbers of GABAergic neurons. Thus, the role of HCFC1 in brain development is not completely understood. Recently, knock-in of both a cblX (HCFC1) and cblX-like (THAP11) allele were created in mice. Knock-in of the cblX-like allele was associated with increased expression of proteins required for ribosome biogenesis. However, the brain phenotypes were not comprehensively studied due to sub-viability and therefore, a mechanism underlying increased ribosome biogenesis was not described. We used a missense, a nonsense, and two conditional zebrafish alleles to further elucidate this mechanism during brain development. We observed contrasting phenotypes at the level of Akt/mTor activation, the number of radial glial cells, and the expression of two downstream target genes of HCFC1, asxl1 and ywhab. Despite these divergent phenotypes, each allele studied demonstrates with a high degree of face validity when compared to the phenotypes reported in the literature. Collectively, these data suggest that individual mutations in the HCFC1 protein result in differential mTor activity which is associated with contrasting cellular phenotypes.