The Evolution of Protein Folds by Creative Destruction

Mechanisms by which new protein folds emerge and diverge pose central questions in biological sciences. Incremental mutation and step-wise adaptation explain relationships between topologically similar protein folds. However, the universe of folds is diverse and riotous, suggesting roles of more potent and creative forces. Sequence and structure similarity are observed between topologically distinct folds, indicating that proteins with distinct folds may share common ancestry. We found evidence of common ancestry between three distinct {beta}-barrel folds: OB, SH3 and cradle loop barrel (CLB). The data suggest a mechanism of fold evolution that interconverts SH3, OB and CLB. This mechanism, which we call creative destruction, can be generalized to explain other examples of fold evolution including circular permutation. In creative destruction, an open reading frame duplicates or otherwise merges with another to produce a fused polypeptide. A merger forces two ancestral domains into a new sequence and spatial context. The fused polypeptide can explore folding landscapes that are inaccessible to either of the independent ancestral domains. However, the folding landscapes of the fused polypeptide are not fully independent of those of the ancestral domains. Creative destruction is thus partially conservative in that a daughter fold would inherit some motifs from the ancestral folds. After a merger and refolding, adaptive processes such as mutation and loss of extraneous segments optimize the new daughter fold. SignificanceMechanisms of emergence and early diversification of structured proteins present deep and difficult problems in evolutionary biology. Here we excavate the deepest evolutionary history, found within the translation machinery, which is an ancient molecular fossil and the birthplace of all proteins. We demonstrate common origins of some of the simplest, oldest and most common protein folds. Furthermore, the data suggest a mechanism, that we call creative destruction, that explains at molecular level how simple folds spawn more complex folds. In this mechanism, new folds emerge from old folds via gene duplication, expression, exploration of new folding landscapes and adaptation. Creative destruction explains the facile emergence of complex from simple architectures in a funneled exploration.