Independent adoptions of a set of proteins found in the matrix of the mineralized shell-like eggcase of Argonaut octopuses

The Argonaut octopus, commonly called the paper nautilus, has a spiral-coiled shell-like eggcase. As the main characteristics, the eggcase has no internal septum, is composed entirely of calcite with chitosan being the main polycarbonate and is reportedly formed by organic materials secreted from the membranes of the arms. Meanwhile, the biomineralized external "true" shells of the Mollusks, which includes the Cephalopods, are secreted from the mantle tissue. Therefore, the histological origin of the two shells is completely different. The question of how the Argonauts, which phylogenetically diverged from the completely shell-less octopuses, could form a converging shell-like external structure has thus intrigued biologists for a long time. To answer this question, we performed a multi-omics analysis of the transcriptome and proteome of the two congeneric Argonaut species, Argonauta argo and A. hians. Our result indicates that the shell-like eggcase is not a homolog of the shell, even at the protein level, because the Argonauts apparently recruited a different set of protein repertoires to as eggcase matrix proteins (EcMPs). However, we also found the homologs of three shell matrix proteins (SMPs) of the Conchiferan Mollusks, Pif-like, SOD, and TRX, in the eggcase matrix. The proteins were also found in the only surviving shelled Cephalopods, the nautiloid Nautilus pompilius. Phylogenetic analysis revealed that homologous genes of the Conchiferan SMPs and EcMPs were found in the draft genome of shell-less octopuses. Our result reported here thus suggests that the SMP-coding genes are conserved in both shelled and shell-less Cephalopods. Meanwhile, the Argonauts adopted some of the SMP-coding genes and other non-SMP-coding genes, to form a convergent, non-homologous biomineralized external structure, the eggcase, which is autapomorphic to the group.