Pleiotropy is associated with fitness consequences of new mutations in mutation accumulation lines

Understanding the mechanisms by which mutations affect fitness and the distribution of mutational effects are central goals in evolutionary biology. Mutation accumulation (MA) lines have long been an important tool for understanding the effect of new mutations on fitness, phenotypic variation, and mutational parameters. However, there is a clear gap in predicting the effect of specific new mutations to their effects on fitness. Here, we complete gene ontology analysis and metabolomics experiments on Arabidopsis thaliana MA lines to determine how spontaneous mutations directly affect global metabolic output in lines that have measured fitness consequences. For these analyses, we compared three lines with relative fitness consistently higher than the unmutated progenitor and three lines with lower relative fitness as measured in four different field trials. In a gene ontology analysis, we find that the high fitness lines were significantly enriched in mutations in or near genes with transcription regulator activity. We also find that although they do not have an average difference in the number of mutations, low fitness lines have significantly more metabolic subpathways disrupted than high fitness lines. Taken together, these results suggest that the effect of a new mutation on fitness depends less on the specific metabolic pathways disrupted and more on the pleiotropic effects of those mutations, and that organisms can explore a considerable amount of physiological space with only a few mutations. Significance StatementAs the source of all genetic variation, new mutations are crucial for understanding how organisms adapt to their environment. However, the ways in which new mutations affect the range of metabolic reactions that occur in the cell is unknown. With a combination of gene functional analyses and measurement of the small molecules that drive cellular function and physiology, we find that mutations associated with high fitness are disproportionately found in or near proteins-coding genes that regulate the specific timing and location of gene expression and are less disruptive of cellular physiology.