Examination of digital images from Macaulay Library to determine avian molt strategies: A case study on molts and plumages in eight species of North American hummingbirds

I examined a total of 27,581 images of 6.345 individuals from the Cornell Lab of Ornithologys Macaulay Library to clarify conflicting reports on molt and plumage strategies in eight species of hummingbirds that breed or have bred primarily in the southwestern United States. Fixed replacement sequences from two nodes among primaries and two nodes among secondaries were found without exception, conforming to the findings of previous studies. I concluded that the preformative molt is limited to partial in three species, partial to incomplete in three species, partial to complete in one species, and complete in one species. These molt strategies could be interpreted as having differentiated through synapomorphy, with species between currently recognized clades varying in the extent of their preformative molts; however, given the plastic nature of molt strategies, I predict that this variation will be shaped more by environmental factors than by synapomorphy. Results of this study additionally clarify molt terminology in Trochilidae as based on homologies and establish new criteria for age determinations. The Macaulay Library clearly provides an important resource for the investigation of avian molts and plumages. The results of a validation exercise that I conducted indicate that banders and field ornithologists with a wide range of previous experience can collect accurate data in this manner. I present a road map for such studies and suggest many other questions on avian molt that can also be investigated, including how timing of molts vary geographically and by habitat and how remigial replacement sequences proceed in little-known bird families. I encourage contributors to the Macaulay Library to take and upload images of birds in molt or in worn plumages.