Spatial distribution of local patch extinctions drives recovery dynamics in metacommunities

Human activities lead more and more to the disturbance of plant and animal communities with local extinctions as a consequence. While these negative effects are clearly visible at a local scale, it is less clear how such local patch extinctions affect regional processes, such as metacommunity dynamics and the distribution of diversity in space. Since local extinctions may not be isolated events in space but rather cluster together, it is crucial to investigate their effects in a spatially explicit framework. Here, we use experimental microcosms and numerical simulations to understand the relationship between local patch extinctions and metacommunity dynamics. More specifically, we investigate the effects of the amount and spatial autocorrelation of extinctions in a full factorial design. Experimentally, we found that local patch extinctions increased inter-patch ({beta}-) diversity by creating differences between perturbed and unperturbed patches and at the same time increased local (-) diversity by delaying the competitive exclusion of inferior competitors. Most importantly, recolonization dynamics depended more strongly on the spatial distribution of patch extinctions than on the amount of extinctions per se. Clustered local patch extinctions reduced mixing between perturbed and unperturbed patches which led to slower recovery, lower -diversity in unperturbed patches and higher {beta}-diversity. Results from a metacommunity model matched the experimental observations qualitatively when the model included ranked competitive interactions, giving a hint at the underlying mechanisms. Our results highlight that local patch extinctions can increase the diversity within and between communities, that the strength of these effects depends on the spatial distribution of extinctions and that the effects of local patch extinctions can spread regionally, throughout a landscape. These findings are highly relevant for conservation and management of spatially structured communities under global change.