Free-living psychrophilic bacteria of the genus Psychrobacter are descendents of pathobionts

Host-adapted microbiota are generally thought to have evolved from free-living ancestors. This process is in principle reversible, but examples are few. The genus Psychrobacter (family Moraxellaceae, phylum Gamma-Proteobacteria) includes species inhabiting diverse and mostly polar environments, such as sea ice and marine animals. To probe Psychrobacters evolutionary history, we analyzed 85 Psychrobacter strains by comparative genomics and phenotyping under 24 different growth conditions. Genome-based phylogeny shows Psychrobacter are derived from Moraxella, which are warm-adapted pathobionts. Psychrobacter strains form two ecotypes based on growth temperature: flexible (FE, growth at 4 - 37{degrees}C), and restricted (RE, 4 - 25{degrees}C). FE strains, which can be either phylogenetically basal or derived, have smaller genomes and higher transposon copy numbers. RE strains have larger genomes, and show genomic adaptations towards a psychrophilic lifestyle and are phylogenetically derived only. We then assessed Psychrobacter abundance in 86 mostly wild polar bear stools and tested persistence of select strains in germfree mice. Psychrobacter (both FE and RE) was enriched in stool of polar bears feeding on mammals, but only FE strains persisted in germfree mice. Together these results indicate growth at 37{degrees}C is ancestral in Psychrobacter, lost in many derived species, and likely necessary to colonize the mammalian gut.