Pisum sativum has no competitive responses to neighbours: a case study in reproducible ecology

Plant-plant competition is ubiquitous in nature. However, studying below ground behaviour of roots has always posed certain difficulties. Pea (Pisum sativum L.) has become a sort of model species for ecological studies about how plant roots respond to neighbouring plant roots and barriers in soil. However, published results point in several different directions. This has sometimes been interpreted as pea having sophisticated context dependent responses that can change in complex ways depending on its surroundings. To explore this further, here, we combine the result of five new experiments with published results to examine 18 unique experiments from 7 different studies for a total of 254 replicates. We used a Bayesian hierarchical meta-analysis approach to estimating the likely effect size from the available data, as well as quantify heterogeneity among different experiments, studies and cultivars. The posterior distributions show that, at the coarsest possible scale of total root production, it is unlikely that P. sativum root growth is influenced by either neighbours or barriers to root growth imposed by the walls of pots that vary in volume. We suggest that further work should consider repeating experiments that reported finer scale root plasticity in pea at the rhizosphere scale, and also consider alternative model species for the study of plant root responses to external cues.