Back

Physician attitudes about abortion at a Midwestern academic medical center

Schmuhl, N. B.; Rice, L. W.; Wautlet, C. K.; Higgins, J. A.

2020-05-12 sexual and reproductive health
10.1101/2020.05.08.20094540
Show abstract

BackgroundAlmost every medical professional organization supports abortion access. Meanwhile, federal and state-level policies continue to erode abortion-related healthcare. Physicians are instrumental to abortion access, and their evidence-based attitudes could significantly influence public understanding. However, most studies of physician attitudes about abortion focus on specific subgroups. A study of abortion attitudes among a broader population of clinicians is important for at least three reasons. First, results could provide insights and strategies to improve access and reduce stigma at academic medical centers and beyond. Second, findings could explain discrepancies between expressions of support for abortion by the medical community and the inability or unwillingness of the same community to provide sufficient access to abortion services. Third, gauging the climate of opinion among physicians in a politically contested state is likely to be informative given that most abortion-related judicial decisions will occur in state-versus federal-level courts, and physician attitudes could potentially influence public policy. ObjectiveTo use leading survey methodologies to assess abortion-related attitudes among all physicians at the largest academic medical center in a politically contested Midwestern state. Study DesignInvestigators developed a cross-sectional survey to gauge abortion-related knowledge, attitudes, and practices. The universitys survey research center disseminated the survey to all 1,357 physician faculty members of the school of medicine and public health using a web and mail mixed-mode methodology (67% response rate). Analyses included chi-squared tests and binary logistic regression models of support for abortion procedures and willingness to consult in abortion care. ResultsAcross more than 20 specialties and all sociodemographic categories, physicians reported strong support for abortion. Majorities expressed support for medication (81%) and surgical abortion (80%), that abortion should be legal in all or most cases (88%), and that a state law banning abortion would make womens health worse (91%). While nearly all physicians (94%) care for women of reproductive age, most (69%) reported no opportunity to participate in abortion care and fewer than half (44%) knew whom to contact to refer a patient for abortion care. Female physicians and those who considered their expertise relevant to abortion were more supportive, while physicians of color and highly religious physicians were less supportive. Few physicians reported participating in any aspect of abortion care (14%), though nearly two-thirds were willing to consult in such care (65%). Those with relevant expertise were more willing to consult, while physicians of color and highly religious physicians were less willing. While most physicians said they support unrestricted access to abortion (63%) and the efforts of abortion providers (70%) "a lot," a majority perceived relatively less support among their professional peers, revealing a climate of pluralistic ignorance. ConclusionsDespite overwhelming support for abortion among this population, participation in any aspect of abortion care is remarkably low. Physicians across all disciplines need clear training and guidelines on how to refer patients for abortion care, and abortion should be normalized and integrated into mainstream medicine. Given professional organizations support of abortion and physicians cultural influence, these results can be used to inform public policy regarding abortion access.

Matching journals

1
PLOS ONE
Public Library of Science (PLoS) · based on 1737 published papers
Top 13%
1.8× avg
2
BMJ Open
BMJ · based on 553 published papers
Top 10%
3.0× avg
3
Journal of Racial and Ethnic Health Disparities
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 11 published papers
#1
158× avg
4
PLOS Global Public Health
Public Library of Science (PLoS) · based on 287 published papers
Top 5%
5.5× avg
5
SSM - Population Health
Elsevier BV · based on 17 published papers
#1
113× avg
6
Sexually Transmitted Infections
BMJ · based on 20 published papers
Top 0.4%
57× avg
7
BMC Public Health
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 148 published papers
Top 9%
3.3× avg
8
Health Expectations
Wiley · based on 12 published papers
Top 0.3%
39× avg
9
JAMA Network Open
American Medical Association (AMA) · based on 125 published papers
Top 10%
2.4× avg
10
Preventive Medicine
Elsevier BV · based on 11 published papers
#1
34× avg
11
Journal of General Internal Medicine
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 19 published papers
Top 2%
12× avg
12
BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 19 published papers
Top 1%
14× avg
13
Scientific Reports
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 701 published papers
Top 74%
1.5%
14
JMIR Formative Research
JMIR Publications Inc. · based on 31 published papers
Top 3%
6.9× avg
15
Vaccines
MDPI AG · based on 131 published papers
Top 5%
2.8× avg
16
PLOS Digital Health
Public Library of Science (PLoS) · based on 88 published papers
Top 11%
1.6× avg
17
Journal of Clinical Investigation
American Society for Clinical Investigation · based on 50 published papers
Top 3%
5.8× avg
18
Archives of Clinical and Biomedical Research
Fortune Journals · based on 18 published papers
Top 2%
7.2× avg
19
BMJ Global Health
BMJ · based on 95 published papers
Top 12%
0.8%
20
BMC Infectious Diseases
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 110 published papers
Top 18%
1.6× avg
21
European Journal of Human Genetics
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 25 published papers
Top 3%
9.1× avg
22
British Journal of General Practice
Royal College of General Practitioners · based on 22 published papers
Top 2%
6.9× avg
23
Annals of Epidemiology
Elsevier BV · based on 19 published papers
Top 2%
8.7× avg
24
BMC Medical Education
Springer Science and Business Media LLC · based on 16 published papers
Top 1%
4.2× avg