Genomic novelty versus convergence in the basis of adaptation to whole genome duplication

Whole genome duplication (WGD) occurs across kingdoms and can promote adaptation. However, a sudden increase in chromosome number, as well as changes in physiology, are traumatic to conserved processes. Previous work in Arabidopsis arenosa revealed a coordinated genomic response to WGD, involving physically interacting meiosis proteins, as well as changes related to cell cycle and ion homeostasis. Here we ask: is this coordinated shift in the same processes repeated in another species following WGD? To answer this, we resequenced and cytologically assessed replicated populations from a diploid/autotetraploid system, Cardamine amara, and test the hypothesis that gene and process-level convergence will be prevalent between these two WGDs adaptation events. Interestingly, we find that gene-level convergence is negligible, with no more in common than would be expected by chance. This was most clear at meiosis-related genes, consistent with our cytological assessment of somewhat lower meiotic stability in C. amara, despite establishment and broad occurrence of the autotetraploid in nature. In contrast, obvious convergence at the level of functional processes, including meiotic cell cycle, chromosome organisation and stress signalling was evident. This indicates that the two autotetraploids survived challenges attendant to WGD via contrasting solutions, modifying different players from similar processes. Overall, this work gives the first insight into the salient adaptations required to cope with a genome-doubled state and brings the first genomic evidence that autopolyploids can utilize multiple trajectories to achieve adaptation to WGD. We speculate that this flexibility increases the likelihood a nascent polyploid overcomes early stringent challenges to later access the spectrum of evolutionary opportunities of polyploidy. Significance statementWhole genome duplication (WGD) is a tremendous mutation and an important evolutionary force. It also presents immediate changes to meiosis and cell physiology that nascent polyploids must overcome to survive. Given the dual facts that WGD adaptation is difficult, but many lineages nevertheless survive WGD, we ask: how constrained are the evolutionary responses to a genome-doubled state? We previously identified candidate genes for WGD adaptation in Arabidopsis arenosa, which has natural diploid and tetraploid variants. Here we test for evolutionary convergence in adaptation to WGD in a species 17 million years distant, Cardamine amara. This work gives the first genomic insight into of how autopolyploids utilize multiple adaptive trajectories to manage a genome-doubled state.